Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Cost vs injury (Score 1) 499

That is similar to here (Indiana); yellow means to clear the intersection. Generally this is taken to mean you can continue through a yellow light if you are already moving, as long as you do not accelerate through the light. If the light is yellow and you are stopped (say a turn lane) but have not yet broken the "plane" of the intersection, you are not permitted to go, if you are already in the intersection but stopped (again, turn lane) you are allowed to finish the turn.

With rules like this, it's a wonder to me that the massive volume of idiots around don't all run into each other more often, honestly.

Comment Re:Cost vs injury (Score 1) 499

From the perspective of a former cycle courier with almost a decade of experience: If everybody followed the letter of the law, traffic in cities would come to a grinding halt in short order. You just go ahead and follow the rules. You'll find people cutting in front of you (and then slamming on their brakes) in short order, and myriad horns blaring at you as you wait for pedestrians to leave the crosswalk (or, depending on your jurisdiction, leave your half of the roadway if a two-way street).

If -everyone- was following the letter of the law, none of what you just described above would be happening. The problem is as soon as a few people choose not to, the entire system falls apart. This may have been your overarching point, but your first sentence seems to contradict that.

Comment Re:Privacy issue: DNA dragnets (Score 1) 513

Not all cops are corrupt, and not all governments want to slam a boot down onto your face forever.

Absolutely true, but in the US at least, corruption exists in any police force of appreciable size such that I would not generally trust any police force in this country. Many police OFFICERS are great people. One of my best friends is a cop, he's a great guy. I still would not trust his department as a whole. FWIW, the largest infractions I've ever committed is downloading a few songs and speeding on occasion. I'm not a criminal in any real sense of the word.

Comment Re:Tweedledee won ! (Score 1) 1576

...The Vietnam Conflict could have been won, without much doubt. However doing so would have been prohibitively expensive both in cost of lives and financially, as well as requiring an entirely different approach to fighting it. The way it was handled, it had a near 0 chance of success.

Comment Re:Aftermarket world (Score 1) 238

And honestly... the wiring isn't that difficult. An engine is a low-tech thing, with lots of simple sensors/controls.

The real changes will be when everything goes electric. Even then, it's just a big radio control car speed control. It has firmware and it can and will be hacked/modified/upgraded.

It's amazing how many Luddites there are on a tech site, when it comes to cars (not meaning you).

Comment Re:Automakers go out of business! (Score 1) 238

From a GM (or subsidiary) dealership? Beyond that, there are aftermarket tools to work on them already, those didn't randomly stop existing when Saab folded. Due to current US regulations, all of the troubleshooting codes for systems diagnostics are already standard (relatively speaking) and published.

Comment Modern... (Score 1) 238

I would much rather work on a modern car than a classic. In fact, my hobby is retrofitting modern components into classic cars, including ECUs. The concepts on this ballot are important because the manufacturers would like to completely lock us out of the ECU, THAT would be an issue. As is, as long as they ECU can be talked to, and we can have basic access to it, it's not particularly difficult to work on a modern car (and they self-diagnose far better than classics).

If you really need to control an engine and don't have access to the original ECU for some reason, replacing it with an aftermarket ECU is not difficult, it just requires (very basic) coding knowledge. The basic guts of an ICE haven't changed much, and even variable valve timing and direct injection are not particularly complex concepts to tune. The fact that the skill set to work on modern engines is different than classic engines doesn't mean that they are worse or harder to work on, it just means you need different skills. This is like people saying that computers suck to work on now that they aren't full of tubes, that's only true if you only know how to work on tubes.

Comment Re:They just need to... (Score 1) 284

Lots. Most codes are required to be published to allow following of standards, it's just a matter of knowing where to find them (a critical skill if you wish to run a company who makes tools for this).

My eBay scanner + Torque app on my phone can read some of the BCM and other system codes, and it's a 5 dollar app on Android. Snap-On and Matco tools can do much, much more and are not prohibitively expensive if you are speaking from the shop standpoint vs. home hobbyist. It's worth noting that most things utilize CANbus now also.

Comment Re:They just need to... (Score 1) 284

You've added a great deal of drama to the subject without reason. The tools that allow basic changes and in-depth diagnostics are available from major automotive tool manufacturers, it's not some secret underground group. It is also illegal for a manufacturer to void the warranty on the vehicle if they cannot conclusively prove that the modification in fact caused the under-warranty failure. You are free to imagine whatever you wish, but you are incorrect in your understanding of the subject.

Slashdot Top Deals

Is your job running? You'd better go catch it!

Working...