Comment Re:Wow. (Score 1) 693
I don't think that it is cool at all but rather a capitulation to fear of lawsuits. If I were one of the legitimate students I would be enraged that the cheaters were being given a second chance after getting caught. The message the university is sending is that if you cheat, get caught, and say 'aww shucks, I promise not to do it again' that you can get away with it. This isn't going to be the first time these students cheated and if it is the last it is only because they are scared of getting caught not because they recognize the value of hard work or that it is wrong. I suspect that the majority of these students will cheat again if given the oppurtunity, obviously not using the publishers key but by some other technique.
Academic censure or expulsion are the only acceptable outcomes for clear cut cases of cheating. Unfortunately I suspect that the truth is that their certainty of who the cheaters are is rather less than the claimed 95% and their ability to prove it is almost non-existent so this approach is being taken to avoid the inevitable lawsuits that would occur with an expulsion. Hopefully they take the data from the new exam and cross-reference it with the old results to improve their identification of cheaters in the future at least.