Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Glad to see it on Slashdot (Score 1) 92

If your interested in the controvesy, you can read the peer reviews and authors responses of a couple of papers they've had rejected from Atmospheric Physics and Chemistry (https://www.atmos-chem-phys-discuss.net/acpd-2008-0250/). Its an open access journal and not only are the manuscripts free, but anyone in the community can comment on papers in the review process and the peer reviews, while annonymous are at least transparent.

Comment Re:Open Source [Re:What's The Problem?] (Score 2) 74

It doesn't need to be endorsed by a university, a learned society is sufficient. My highest cited papers have been published in the open access 'Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics' which is run by the European Geophysical Union, its nowhere near nature or science in impact factor, but it is a respectable mid tier journal. The writer pays up front for hosting/typesetting etc the cost of which you put into your grant.

Its much more open than a traditional journal. They publish the initial submission, the reviewer comments the response to reviewer comments and the final paper. In addition, members of the scientific community can add comments in the same way as the reviewers, albeit not anonymously.

Comment Re:False dichotomy of the guilty conscience (Score 1) 332

I'm sorry I did only address the first boming, with regards to the second: There were three separate coup attempts and the cabinet were still debating what to do, so a significant proportion of the army and navy leadership were willing to continue the war anyway, I think there was also some debate as to whether the americans only had one bomb. The second bombing removed any ambiguity as to what the allies could do and what they were willing to do. If we have 250000 deaths/month in the empire and the 2nd bombing only brought forward the cabinets inevitable decision to surrender by a week, it would still be death neutral, and its far from certain that decision was inevitable. The co-propersity sphere was a vast area of the earth, the soviets had only invaded Mancuria in northeast China. It would have had little impact on the divisions in southern China, Burma, south east asia, the east indies, the pacific etc.

Slashdot Top Deals

Real Users never use the Help key.

Working...