Comment Re:"Which is why we're not going to prove anything (Score 1) 273
Because, uh. We have nothing to prove. Yes. That's it. In conclusion please ignore the competitor which shall no longer be acknowledged as existing. As for myself I must resign for personal reasons and go live as a hermit in Tibet.
There are some good reasons others have stated as to why the comparison was not truly meaningful. Engineering Explained made a video on the physics here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?... .
Fact is, two things matter in a tug-of-war: traction and stall torque. Tesla pulled a 2WD vehicle with no weight in the back using a 4WD vehicle. And given all the batteries and copper and steel the electric motors are made out of, the Tesla truck is probably ridiculously heavy (and since it takes more work to move more weight, it's less efficient). Of course it was going to win, but because of physics, not because of any special or desirable physical property of the Tesla truck.
Something else that always gets me though is the claim that "oh yeah, electric motors produce TONS of low-end torque! Gas(or Diesel, whatever) engines produce 0!"........ Yeah? Yeah. You need a transmission. But we have those. There are also these nifty things called torque converters, so coupled with selectable gear reduction and a torque multiplier fluid coupling, I really question whether the stall torque at the wheels on an electric vehicle is higher than a comparable gas or diesel pickup truck... Could be, but I've never heard of anyone testing it, so I assume everyone's just talking out their butt because they heard someone say it on the internet and now they're an expert in engineering...
End of the day, internal combustion engines still have a higher energy density, which means your range for a given amount of weight is likely going to be better (You can get absurd range on a pickup truck by adding a second tank, which people do, and it still surely weighs less than the batteries in a Tesla truck). And you can refuel in a short period of time...