Find and compare the best Artificial Intelligence software for Git in 2026
Sort:
Use the comparison tool below to compare the top Artificial Intelligence software for Git on the market. You can filter results by user reviews, pricing, features, platform, region, support options, integrations, and more.
-
1
Windmill
Windmill
$120 per monthWindmill serves as an open-source platform for developers, functioning as a workflow engine that converts scripts into automatically generated user interfaces, APIs, and cron jobs. This innovative tool simplifies the creation of workflows and data pipelines, making it easier to construct complex applications that handle large volumes of data. Windmill supports multiple programming languages, allowing developers to write and deploy applications significantly faster, up to ten times quicker, while ensuring high reliability and observability through its self-hosted job orchestrator. Among its features are auto-generated user interfaces tailored to script parameters, a low-code application editor for crafting custom UIs, and a flow editor that utilizes a drag-and-drop approach to workflow design. Additionally, Windmill automatically manages dependencies, incorporates strong permission controls, and offers comprehensive monitoring capabilities. Users can trigger workflows using various methods, such as webhooks, scheduled tasks, CLI commands, Slack messages, or emails. Furthermore, developers have the flexibility to write their scripts in their preferred local code editors, allowing them to preview and seamlessly deploy their work using the command line interface, streamlining the overall development process. This robust platform ultimately empowers users to create sophisticated applications with minimal effort. -
2
GitSummarize
GitSummarize
FreeGitSummarize converts any GitHub repository into an extensive documentation center that utilizes AI technology, thereby improving both the comprehension of the codebase and collaborative efforts. Users can effortlessly create in-depth documentation for various projects, including React, Next.js, Transformers, VSCode, TensorFlow, and Go, by merely substituting 'hub' with 'summarize' in the GitHub URL. The platform features an intuitive chat interface that offers a rich web experience for user interaction, along with a Git-based checkpoint system that monitors changes in the workspace throughout different tasks. By simplifying the documentation process, GitSummarize not only enhances the quality of information available but also boosts overall developer efficiency. Ultimately, it serves as a valuable tool for teams seeking to optimize their workflow and improve project outcomes. -
3
Revolte
Revolte.ai
$149/month Revolte is an AI-native software engineering platform that helps development teams automate the complete software delivery lifecycle from initial requirements through production operations. Rather than focusing only on AI code generation, the platform executes planning, development, testing, deployment, release management, runtime monitoring, and operational workflows across the entire SDLC. Engineers define project requirements, approve outcomes, and maintain governance while Revolte handles repetitive engineering tasks through coordinated AI agents. The platform integrates with existing tools including Jira, Git, Figma, Kubernetes, Terraform, Slack, Grafana, GitLab, AWS, Google Cloud, and other engineering services, allowing organizations to adopt AI without replacing their current toolchain. Revolte supports use cases including new application development, legacy application modernization, production operations, and continuous feature evolution. Agent Harness allows teams to define platform requirements in YAML, automatically provisioning environments, infrastructure, and services needed to build and operate applications. Delivery Intelligence provides visibility into software delivery performance while runtime observability helps monitor production systems and respond to operational issues. Developer-in-the-loop workflows ensure engineers remain responsible for reviews, approvals, and deployment decisions while AI accelerates execution. By combining workflow orchestration, AI automation, and engineering governance, Revolte helps organizations release software faster, improve delivery consistency, and reduce operational overhead. -
4
Mendel
Mendel
FreeMendel is an innovative platform that utilizes AI to enhance code intelligence by automating the review process for pull requests, identifying complexity and compliance concerns, and providing valuable insights for teams. By implementing agentic AI workflows, Mendel significantly boosts engineering productivity through features such as automated code evaluations, real-time performance metrics, and advanced analyses of repositories and codebases, while also conducting smart checks for dependencies and compliance. This platform offers actionable insights derived from both repositories and developer contributions, which empowers teams to effectively monitor performance and tackle bottlenecks. Additionally, Mendel facilitates repository scans through functions like docstring detection, complexity assessments, and classification of issues. It further enhances security by automating checks for outdated libraries and vulnerable dependencies across the codebase. With its seamless integration into existing Git workflows, Mendel ensures an effortless transition, delivering comprehensive AI-powered reviews in an instant, thus transforming the way teams approach code quality management. -
5
Thunder Compute
Thunder Compute
$0.35 per hourThunder Compute delivers cheap cloud GPUs for companies, researchers, and developers running demanding AI and machine learning workloads. The platform gives users fast access to H100, A100, and RTX A6000 GPUs for LLM training, inference, fine-tuning, image generation, ComfyUI workflows, PyTorch jobs, CUDA applications, deep learning pipelines, model serving, and other GPU-intensive compute tasks. Thunder Compute is designed for teams that want affordable GPU cloud infrastructure with a strong developer experience, clear pricing, and minimal operational friction. Instead of dealing with the cost and complexity of legacy cloud vendors, users can deploy on-demand GPU instances with persistent storage, rapid provisioning, straightforward management, and scalable compute capacity. Thunder Compute is a strong fit for startups building AI products, engineering teams that need cloud GPUs for inference, and organizations looking for GPU hosting that is both economical and reliable. If you are searching for cheap H100s, A100 cloud instances, affordable GPUs for AI, or a RunPod alternative with transparent pricing and a simple interface, Thunder Compute provides a modern option for high-performance cloud GPU rental and AI infrastructure. Thunder Compute supports teams building and deploying modern AI applications that need dependable access to cheap cloud GPUs for both experimentation and production. From prototype training runs to large-scale inference and batch processing, the platform is designed to reduce infrastructure friction and accelerate iteration. For users comparing GPU cloud providers, Thunder Compute stands out with affordable pricing, fast access to top-tier GPUs, and a developer-friendly experience built around real AI workflows. -
6
Parlant
Parlant
FreeParlant is an open-source framework that is ready for production and designed specifically for creating AI chat agents that adhere to compliance standards while effectively managing increasing complexity. It empowers developers to construct conversational agents that are adaptive, iterative, and transparent by utilizing natural-language behavior modeling techniques which include various elements like guidelines, journeys, canned responses, retrievers, glossaries, and tools, all of which can be version-controlled through Git. The framework's guidelines allow for nuanced adjustments to agent behavior based on context, while journeys outline multi-step interaction pathways; canned responses maintain uniformity in critical situations, and explainability tools offer insights into the reasoning behind decisions made by the agents. Additionally, the tools necessitate alignment with guidelines for operation, creating a clear distinction between business logic and conversational behavior, which facilitates collaboration between developers and business professionals. Moreover, built-in functionalities such as session persistence, tracking of tool results across sessions, and an easily integrable React chat widget further enhance the installation process, making it straightforward for developers to implement. This comprehensive approach ensures that users can create highly functional and compliant conversational agents tailored to specific needs. -
7
Rafter
Rafter
$39Rafter is a security scanning platform designed with developers in mind, enabling the identification and resolution of vulnerabilities in GitHub repositories through a simple click or command. Its integration is smooth via a web-based dashboard, command-line interface, or REST API, allowing for the scanning of JavaScript, TypeScript, and Python code to uncover various issues such as exposed API keys, SQL injection vulnerabilities, XSS flaws, insecure dependencies, hardcoded credentials, and weaknesses in authentication. The results are organized into three clear categories: “Errors,” “Warnings,” and “Improvements,” each providing in-depth explanations, specific code locations, remediation guidance, and formatted prompts that can be easily utilized in AI coding tools. Users can access findings in both JSON and Markdown formats, automate scans as part of CI/CD pipelines, and seamlessly integrate scan results into their existing workflows. Rafter’s flexible approach accommodates no-code, low-code, and full-code environments, ensuring that developers can implement proactive security measures early in the software development process, making it not only effortless but also scalable as project requirements grow. This adaptability allows teams to maintain a robust security posture while focusing on delivering high-quality software efficiently. -
8
Brokk
Brokk
$20 per monthBrokk is an innovative AI-driven code assistant designed to manage extensive and intricate codebases by equipping language models with a deep, compiler-grade comprehension of code organization, meaning, and interdependencies. It facilitates effective context management by selectively integrating summaries, diffs, or complete files into a workspace, allowing the AI to focus on pertinent sections of a codebase that may contain millions of lines instead of processing everything at once. With features such as Quick Context, which recommends files based on their embeddings and structural significance; Deep Scan, which employs advanced models to identify files that require editing or further summarization; and Agentic Search, which provides a multi-step exploration of symbols, call graphs, or usages throughout the project, Brokk enhances the coding experience significantly. Its architecture is rooted in static analysis through Joern, enabling type inference that extends beyond basic Abstract Syntax Trees (ASTs), while JLama is utilized for rapid embedding inference to assist with context modifications. Offered as an independent Java application rather than a plugin for an Integrated Development Environment (IDE), Brokk permits users to oversee AI-driven workflows with clarity and precision, ensuring a more streamlined development process overall. This unique approach empowers developers to navigate complex codebases with greater ease and efficiency. -
9
CodeBanana
CodeBanana
$36 per monthCodeBanana is an innovative platform for collaborative coding that focuses on making software development more inclusive and teamwork-oriented. It features live editing capabilities similar to those found in “Google Docs for code,” allowing developers, designers, and project managers to collaborate in real-time within the same project environment. With an integrated AI assistant that comprehensively understands the entire repository and documentation, users can engage in conversational interactions to enhance productivity. The platform also provides shared virtual environments, ensuring that everyone can operate under the same configuration in seconds, thereby resolving the common issue of “it’s-working-on-my-machine.” Additionally, non-technical team members can easily participate through a user-friendly interface, while technical personnel benefit from intelligent suggestions and optimized workflows tailored to the project. CodeBanana is designed to effectively connect different roles within a team, ensuring everyone remains on the same page regarding context, coding decisions, and project objectives, ultimately fostering a more cohesive working environment. This holistic approach not only improves collaboration but also drives innovation across diverse teams. -
10
CodinIT.dev
CodinIT.dev
CodinIT.dev is an open-source platform that uses AI to turn plain-language instructions into full-stack applications in just a few minutes. Instead of writing code from scratch, users describe the type of software they need, and the system builds the frontend, backend, database structure, and deployment configuration automatically. The service connects with more than 19 AI models — such as OpenAI, Anthropic Claude, Google Gemini, and Mistral — giving users flexibility in how their apps are generated. Its in-browser WebContainer workspace provides instant code execution, live previews, a built-in terminal, and Git integration without requiring local setup. CodinIT.dev supports a wide range of frameworks, including React, Vue, Angular, Svelte, Next.js, Nuxt, Astro, and React Native. Applications can be deployed quickly to platforms like Vercel, Netlify, or GitHub Pages, and users can link directly to backend or database tools such as Supabase. All generated code can be exported, ensuring complete project ownership. Designed for both developers and non-technical creators, CodinIT.dev simplifies the process of building modern applications by letting users generate production-ready software from a simple text prompt. -
11
Fusion
Builder.io
$24 per monthFusion serves as an AI-driven development platform that seamlessly merges design, product management, and engineering processes by linking directly to your codebase, design system, and tools. This innovative platform empowers teams to visually create and modify responsive, production-ready user interfaces by utilizing existing repositories, design tokens, and APIs; users can easily import Figma designs, connect their GitHub or other Git providers, and issue changes using natural language, which the system converts into pull requests or live previews. It features real-time canvas editing with exceptional pixel precision, comprehends your components, styles, and backend architecture, and allows any team member—including designers, project managers, and developers—to construct features, prototypes, and fully interactive experiences without the need to manually code each element. With built-in workflow integration, users can trigger builds through Slack mentions, Jira tickets, or discussions around design, while also tracking progress, reviewing generated branches, and merging into standard CI/CD pipelines. This streamlined approach not only enhances collaboration but also increases efficiency across teams, making the development process more intuitive and accessible for everyone involved. -
12
Super
Super
$15 per monthSuperworks is an integrated cloud-based workforce management solution that enhances the entire employee lifecycle, covering everything from hiring to retirement. The platform features an applicant tracking system (ATS) for job postings and monitoring candidates, a human resource management system (HRMS) for consolidating employee data and automating updates, and payroll automation that ensures compliance along with bonus and deduction calculations. Additionally, it supports performance management through goal-setting, feedback mechanisms, and performance reviews, while also facilitating time and activity tracking to boost productivity. Mobile teams benefit from field-force dispatch capabilities, and users can utilize built-in internal chat and collaboration features. The platform further includes tools for asset and project management, employee feedback surveys, and dashboards that provide insights into HR metrics, payroll statuses, and resource utilization. Superworks prioritizes support for multiple locations and companies, offering seamless access via dedicated iOS and Android applications, enabling both employees and managers to connect from virtually anywhere, thus enhancing organizational efficiency and communication. -
13
Emdash
Emdash
FreeEmdash serves as an orchestration layer that allows you to execute numerous coding agents simultaneously, each within its own distinct Git worktree, enabling you to address various subtasks or experiments concurrently without any interference. It is designed to be provider-agnostic, allowing you to select from a range of AI models and command-line interfaces, such as Claude Code and Codex, tailored to your specific workflow requirements. With Emdash, you can directly assign issues or tickets from platforms like Linear, GitHub, or Jira to a selected agent, enabling you to observe multiple agents working in parallel in real time. The user interface provides live updates on agent status and activities, and as soon as agents produce code, you can easily review differences, add comments, and initiate pull requests, all within the Emdash environment. Each agent operates within its own worktree, ensuring changes remain isolated and comparable, which facilitates safe testing of various implementations or strategies side by side. This unique setup not only enhances productivity but also encourages experimentation without the risk of code conflicts. -
14
Mistral Vibe
Mistral AI
FreeMistral Vibe is an intelligent AI agent platform that enables users to manage research, content creation, workflow automation, and software development from a single environment. The platform is designed to handle long-duration tasks by connecting with internal systems, business applications, documents, calendars, communication tools, and external information sources. Users can quickly generate reports, strategic briefs, presentations, meeting preparations, and business documents while leveraging AI-driven insights. For developers, Mistral Vibe offers advanced coding assistance through terminal tools, IDE integrations, web applications, and autonomous background agents. Its coding capabilities support feature development, code reviews, testing, debugging, documentation, dependency updates, and large-scale modernization projects. The platform provides deep codebase understanding, allowing AI agents to reason across files, services, APIs, and architectural components. Organizations can further customize the experience through model training, fine-tuning, and enterprise deployment options. Mistral Vibe also supports workflow automation that moves data between systems, triggers actions, and executes repetitive business processes with minimal manual intervention. By combining productivity, automation, research, and coding capabilities, the platform helps teams work more efficiently and complete projects faster. -
15
Forge Code
Forge Code
$20 per monthForge Code is an AI-driven pair-programming tool that operates within the terminal, allowing users to manage their entire codebase through conversational commands. It integrates effortlessly into your shell environment, meaning there's no need to disrupt your current IDE or workflow; you can continue using the tools you are familiar with. Once activated, Forge Code gains insight into project files, Git history, dependencies, and the surrounding environment, enabling it to grasp the structure of your codebase and respond to queries without needing constant clarifications. It features a dual-agent system, consisting of a “Forge Agent” that carries out code modifications and executes real-time operations, alongside a “Muse Agent” that focuses on planning, evaluating, and reviewing code without making any alterations to your files. Furthermore, Forge Code can be utilized with your chosen AI service providers or self-hosted LLMs, ensuring you maintain complete oversight of your code's handling and the model's operation. This flexibility allows developers to tailor the experience according to their specific needs and preferences. -
16
WunderGraph Cosmo
WunderGraph
$499 per monthWunderGraph is a cutting-edge, open-source API platform that streamlines the integration and management of various APIs from heterogeneous backends like REST, gRPC, Kafka, and GraphQL, allowing developers to create a cohesive, type-safe, and high-performance API interface for modern applications. It features Cosmo, a comprehensive API management solution for federated GraphQL, which encompasses essential functionalities such as schema registry, composition validation, routing, analytics, metrics, tracing, and observability, all of which can be handled through code integrated into existing development workflows instead of relying on separate dashboards. By enabling teams to specify how multiple services should be combined into a single API, WunderGraph simplifies the automatic generation of type-safe client libraries and facilitates the management of authentication, authorization, and API requests through built-in tools that align seamlessly with CI/CD and Git-centered processes. This innovative approach not only enhances productivity but also ensures that developers can focus on building robust applications without being bogged down by the complexities of API integration. -
17
Mesa
Mesa.dev
FreeMesa is an innovative platform that leverages artificial intelligence to enhance code review processes, enabling engineering teams to elevate software quality and confidently deploy code by addressing technical debt before it impacts production. The platform's smart agents are capable of understanding the distinct elements of a team's codebase, business logic, and development standards, allowing them to provide reviews that are contextual and precise, surpassing mere linting or generic suggestions from AI. Users have the flexibility to develop custom review agents that focus on specific issues such as security vulnerabilities, performance optimization, and domain-specific logic, while also selecting from a diverse range of foundational models from notable providers like OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google, which can be optimized for various metrics such as speed, cost-efficiency, or intelligence level. Additionally, Mesa produces comprehensive and consistent descriptions for pull requests utilizing team-defined templates, seamlessly integrating into existing CI/CD workflows, and adjusting to different branching strategies to ensure that quality checks are an integral part of daily development activities. This adaptability not only streamlines the review process but also empowers teams to maintain high standards throughout their software development lifecycle. -
18
Sourcery
Sourcery
$12 per monthSourcery serves as an AI-driven automated code review tool and coding assistant that aims to enhance the quality of code, identify bugs and security vulnerabilities early on, and ensure uniform standards across various projects for developers and engineering teams. It seamlessly integrates with widely-used development platforms like GitHub, GitLab, and integrated development environments (IDEs) such as VS Code and JetBrains, offering immediate, actionable insights on pull requests and in-code edits instead of relying primarily on conventional peer review processes. By leveraging a blend of large language model capabilities and static analysis, Sourcery evaluates code diffs to provide concise summaries, detailed line-by-line recommendations, overarching feedback, and visual representations that clarify suggested modifications, striving to achieve a review standard akin to that of a fellow developer. Within the IDE, it acts as an instant pair programming assistant that highlights possible enhancements, facilitates one-click application of recommendations, and includes an AI chat feature for further support, making it a versatile tool for developers looking to refine their coding practices. Additionally, Sourcery's real-time feedback mechanism fosters a collaborative coding environment, enabling teams to work more efficiently and effectively together. -
19
Kodus
Kodus
$10 per monthKodus is a collaborative, open-source platform that harnesses AI technology for code review, featuring an intelligent agent named Kody that seamlessly integrates with popular Git workflows like GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, and Azure DevOps, aimed at assisting engineering teams in automating and enhancing the quality of their code assessments. By performing thorough analyses on each pull request with a deep understanding of the team’s specific codebase, architecture, workflows, coding standards, and business rules, Kody provides targeted feedback focused on quality, security, performance, and style, rather than offering vague recommendations. Teams have the option to create custom review criteria using natural language or select from a collection of pre-validated rules designed to promote best practices and maintain consistent standards; they can also utilize their own API keys to choose and implement any AI model they prefer. Additionally, Kodus transforms unaddressed suggestions into monitored issues, aids in tracking technical debt, and delivers actionable insights in a manner that minimizes distractions, while supporting more than 30 programming languages to ensure broad applicability across different projects. This comprehensive approach not only streamlines the review process but also fosters a culture of continuous improvement within development teams. -
20
cubic
cubic.dev
$24 per monthCubic is an AI-driven code review solution that streamlines the analysis of pull requests on GitHub, enabling software development teams to identify bugs, maintain coding standards, and accelerate their release cycles by minimizing manual review delays. It provides immediate, context-aware feedback upon the opening of a pull request by analyzing the entire repository's history and recognized patterns, which leads to inline comments that identify bugs, coding anti-patterns, technical debt, and suggestions for enhancements that human reviewers could overlook, along with one-click fix options for straightforward issues. Additionally, Cubic can produce concise summaries of pull requests that clarify the purpose and effects of changes, intelligently organize complex differences into more manageable segments, and feature a chat interface that allows developers to pose questions or navigate the codebase directly on the platform. Teams have the capability to establish customized review protocols and incorporate business context from issue tracking systems such as Jira, Linear, or Asana, ensuring that code reviews not only assess technical quality but also align with acceptance criteria. With its innovative features, Cubic significantly enhances the efficiency of the code review process, fostering collaboration and improving overall software quality. -
21
HunyuanWorld
Tencent
FreeHunyuanWorld-1.0 is an open-source AI framework and generative model created by Tencent Hunyuan, designed to generate immersive, interactive 3D environments from text inputs or images by merging the advantages of both 2D and 3D generation methods into a single cohesive process. Central to the framework is a semantically layered 3D mesh representation that utilizes 360° panoramic world proxies to break down and rebuild scenes with geometric fidelity and semantic understanding, allowing for the generation of varied and coherent spaces that users can navigate and engage with. In contrast to conventional 3D generation techniques that often face challenges related to limited diversity or ineffective data representations, HunyuanWorld-1.0 adeptly combines panoramic proxy creation, hierarchical 3D reconstruction, and semantic layering to achieve a synthesis of high visual quality and structural soundness, while also providing exportable meshes that fit seamlessly into standard graphics workflows. This innovative approach not only enhances the realism of generated environments but also opens new possibilities for creative applications in various industries. -
22
Devant
WSO2
FreeWSO2 Devant is an integration platform designed with AI at its core, enabling businesses to seamlessly connect, integrate, and create intelligent applications across various systems, data sources, and AI services in the modern technological landscape. This platform facilitates connections to generative AI models, vector databases, and AI agents, enriching applications with advanced AI features while addressing complex integration challenges with ease. Devant offers both no-code/low-code and pro-code development experiences, enhanced by AI tools that assist in tasks such as natural-language-based code generation, suggestions, automated data mapping, and testing, all aimed at accelerating integration workflows and improving collaboration between business and IT teams. Furthermore, it boasts a comprehensive library of connectors and templates, allowing users to orchestrate integrations across multiple protocols including REST, GraphQL, gRPC, WebSockets, and TCP, while also ensuring scalability across hybrid and multi-cloud environments, effectively bridging systems, databases, and AI agents for optimal performance. This innovative platform not only streamlines integration processes but also empowers organizations to harness the full potential of AI in their operations. -
23
Pencil
Pencil.dev
FreePencil.dev is an innovative design-in-code platform that utilizes AI to seamlessly integrate visual interface design within development environments such as Cursor, VS Code, and various other IDEs, allowing designers and developers to collaborate without the need for tool handoffs. Centered around an agent-driven Model Context Protocol (MCP) canvas and an accessible design format embedded in your codebase, Pencil enables users to create, refine, and produce pixel-perfect UI screens with the aid of AI, all while maintaining version control in Git alongside their source code, which facilitates branches, merges, and rollbacks akin to traditional coding practices. By incorporating a Figma-like canvas directly into the IDE, it significantly reduces the hassle of switching between different tools, supports the import of frames and assets from Figma while preserving vectors and styles, and allows for manipulation of design elements through intuitive editing panels, layers, and CSS-like properties. Furthermore, AI models assist in the simultaneous generation of screens, flows, and components, enhancing productivity and creativity in the design process. This integration fosters a more cohesive workflow, making it easier for teams to innovate and iterate on their projects efficiently. -
24
Polyscope
Beyond Code
$99 per yearPolyscope is an innovative development environment that prioritizes an agent-first approach, facilitating the orchestration and execution of multiple AI coding agents concurrently to streamline intricate software engineering processes. This platform integrates with sophisticated coding models like Claude Code and OpenAI Codex, allowing users to deploy numerous agents at once while ensuring that each task is handled within its own independent workspace. Each agent operates in a copy-on-write environment, which provides a secure setting for testing various methods, altering files, and implementing changes without jeopardizing the integrity of the original project. With the capability to run numerous AI agents simultaneously, developers can efficiently generate code, examine repositories, debug issues, or explore different solutions within the same codebase. Polyscope is offered as a native tool for macOS, optimized for high-performance agent operation, and provides engineers with a unified interface to monitor agent activities and oversee task management. This environment ultimately enhances productivity by allowing developers to leverage the combined power of multiple AI agents in their projects. -
25
BackAnt
BackAnt
$15 per monthBackAnt is a backend development tool that leverages AI to effortlessly produce production-ready APIs and backend infrastructure based on straightforward prompts or specifications. Functioning mainly as a command-line interface, it facilitates the rapid scaffolding of complete backend applications utilizing the Flask framework, enabling developers to create fully structured projects within seconds rather than through manual processes. Upon executing a generation command or submitting a JSON specification that outlines the necessary endpoints and data structures, the system efficiently constructs the essential elements of a backend application, such as API routes, business-logic services, data repositories, database models, and the initial configuration for application startup. The resulting project adheres to a layered architecture that distinctly separates routing, business logic, and data access, which aids in preserving a clean and scalable codebase. This approach not only accelerates development but also enhances maintainability and adaptability as project requirements evolve over time.