If McDonalds is protected against some guy grabbing two sandwiches and walking out - the same is required for the record companies.
But what protects that same guy from the RIAA/MPAA/**AA bankrupting him and ruining his life for (maybe) sharing a few songs?
I know that my firm regularly lobbies against software piracy in China and India - and am glad they do it. It saves my job
That's more important to you than your civil liberties?
People with only one arm would need special cars anyway - or at least couldn't drive most cars safely, what with the stick shift, wiper blades and handbrake being on the right and the directional and headlights on the left of the steering wheel.
I am pretty sure, the answer is a resounding "Yes". Some things should be kept secret for some time... No one seriously argues against that, even if there are disagreements over whether a particular bit of information needs to be classified or not (and for how long).
There are some things that in an ideal world would be better off kept secret. However the consequences of allowing our government to keep secrets are worse than allowing those secrets to be heard.
Now, if anything needs to be hidden, then somebody has to be making the everyday decisions on what gets classified, and enforcing them. Governments are the most natural pick for that, if only because they are -- by design -- charged with national security.
Governments are the worst choice, as they have the most to gain by abuses of secrecy.
Any "leakers" inside the government usurp that decision-making to themselves and to the Wikileaks. Instead of relying on the judgment of people charged with making it, we will depend on the judgment of the "leaker" and of the Wikileaks editors. Personally, I'd prefer the government officials...
"I was only following orders" has never been a valid defense. You have a conscience for a reason, use it. If you really trust the government more than your own conscience, then by all means obey the law. The rest of us will do what we feel is right.
Thus any leakers (and the Wikileaks personnel) are to be prosecuted
That's how it is in oppressive regimes. This is why it's important that we respect justice more than legality.
The test of intelligent tinkering is to save all the parts. -- Aldo Leopold