Comment Re:Supernova (Score 1) 32
To be fair, having a single snake-like cable connecting all the PCs was a pretty common idea. To us today it seems obviously easier to have individual connections to a central hub or switch, but at the time a common cable was accepted, perhaps to save on the total amount of wiring used. Token Ring also used a single wire, though joined into a loop, and I think there was also Token Bus.
You are right that "transmit, and retry on collision" can never scale. But it is simple and hard to get wrong, as long as everyone is polite enough to wait a little before retrying. I'd say the success of the original Ethernet is an example of "worse is better".