I'm impressed how Perens feels he can just brush away all disagreement with the GPL v3 because "Linus had a personal issue with it, some I'm ignoring that".
Joining the GPL v3 steamroller isn't going to make developers any more willing to use it.
You make a very good point about the artwork - I'm a terrible, terrible artist, both in terms of drawing, and just being good at composition. Getting some better artwork could well be a good idea to make the game smoother to play. You should have seem some of the earlier UI designs. They were REALLY horrible.
Of course back when I played Lemmings, the only hints I could get get was from the other people I went to school with. Now I could just jump on the internet when I get stuck.
I bet if WoW offered two identical releases, one where you started level 1 and one where you could start on any level you wanted most people would choose the second. However, long term that would probably give WoW a worse reputation and an overall loss of sales.
What about the obvious third option - I want to make a game that is the most fun for everyone else?
Even if the aim is the sell the game, what are the features that will sell the game? Just because a bunch of users say they want something, doesn't actually mean that adding that will make the game better, or more popular.
The real question is (I think) one of self-control. In your (and other's) experience, how easy (if at all) should it be to skip through parts of a game? Should users just be trusted to skip whatever and all parts they want, or should they be forced to put more thought and time in, because in the end they will enjoy it more?
I find shell scripting have a nasty habit of not working quiet right when moved between Linux, the BSDs and Mac to be safe, and it's always a pain to write scripts that work correctly with spaces in file names.
Why isn't there (or is there?) a simple python cheat guide, or library, that do the same things as grep, awk, find, mv and xargs?
Now, my figures may be way off, but it looks to me like the last episode of BSG pulled in less than 2 million viewers, unlike Chuck, a fun show I'm currently enjoying, which pulled in around 6 million. (Do correct me if I'm way off).
BSG is a show with a very vocal audience, who enjoy discussing and dissecting every issue all over the internet, despite my best attempts to avoid them. However, I'm not sure it's actually that fun to watch. It certainly wasn't at first.
Who is the fifth cylon? I really couldn't care less. I don't hate BSG, but just to put some perspective on things, for most people it isn't that big.
If people refused to use and pay for buggy applications, they would either get fixed or die off.
For God's sake, stop researching for a while and begin to think!