Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
KDE

Submission + - If You Are Buying Into Ubuntu Phone Claims, You're Being Duped: Aaron Seigo (muktware.com)

sfcrazy writes: KDE's Plasma Active team leader Aaron Seigo (who is bringing out a KDE-powered tablet soon — instead of using Google hardware, and probably Google code, to break Google's hegemony) has raised some concerns around Ubuntu Phone. He says "We can start with the obvious clue: Unity currently does not use QML at all; Ubuntu Phone is pure QML. So, no, it is not the same code, it is not the sort of seamless cross-device technology bridge that they are purporting."

He then concludes, "If you're a Free software developer, user and/or supporter and buying into these claims, I don't know how else to put it other than this: you're being duped. Consider what supporting those who employ such tactics means for Free software."

Our own Bruce Perens said that on Slashdot — "Working for free to make Mark Shuttleworth richer just isn’t very smart."

Feed Techdirt: Arthur Conan Doyle Estate Sued To Show That Sherlock Holmes Is Public Domain (techdirt.com)

A little over three years ago, we had a discussion concerning whether or not Sherlock Holmes was in the public domain. By our understanding of the law, the character absolutely is in the public domain. There is one remaining book -- The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes -- which contains a few stories, that are still covered by copyright, but the characters and most of the written works, are in the public domain. However, the legal representatives of the Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Estate use the fact that one book is still held under copyright to argue that the character is still protected until (at least) 2023. Of course, as with things like Happy Birthday, even if it should be in the public domain, if there's some corporate entity insisting that it's covered by copyright, you'd have to go to court to prove otherwise. And most people don't want to bother.

Thankfully, that just changed when it comes to Sherlock Holmes. Sherlock Holmes scholar, Leslie S. Klinger, was working on a book (with Laurie R. King) called In the Company of Sherlock Holmes, detailing "major mystery/sci-fi/fantasy authors inspired by the Holmes tales." However, the Conan Doyle Estate contacted their publisher, Pegasus Books, demanding a license fee, and saying if they weren't paid, they'd make sure that no major distributors would sell the book. Specifically, the estate directly threatened that:

If you proceed instead to bring out Study in Sherlock II unlicensed, do not expect to see it offered for sale by Amazon, Barnes Noble, and similar retailers. We work with those company's routinely to weed out unlicensed uses of Sherlock Holmes from their offerings, and will not hesitate to do so with your book as well.
Like too many publishers, Pegasus freaked out and refused to publish the book at all, so Klinger has taken it upon himself to file for declaratory judgment. You can see the full filing posted here (and embedded it below).

The lawsuit points out that Sherlock Holmes characters have long been in the public domain, and even that remaining book of stories includes two that are clearly in the public domain, as they were published prior to 1923. But, most importantly "none of the Sherlock Holmes Story Elements first appeared in any of the stories that were collected in The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes." In other words, the entirety of copyright protected elements in the character were published outside of that one book, and are now in the public domain.

The lawsuit also notes that Klinger and King's publisher on an earlier book, A Study in Sherlock did, in fact, pay a license to the estate, but they did not concede any of the legal arguments. When the estate threatened Klinger, he correctly explained that no license was needed, but he's still dealing with the fallout from his publisher getting cold feet. Thus, he's asking the court to state, definitively, that the character is in the public domain. Kudos for Klinger for taking this on. We need more people willing to stand up for the public domain. Also, jeers to Pegasus for not being the one to take this on and for freaking out over the bogus threat.

Permalink | Comments | Email This Story



Comment Re:Underestimating (Score 1) 350

No, the AC has a point. You're not going to cure an alcoholic with this and you might even kill hi with it. I know quite a few alkies, both practicing and reformed, and few with a bad addiction ever stop until they hit rock bottom. Even after an alcoholic reforms, relapse isn't only possible but usually likely. And an alcoholic will literally drink himself to death, either from overdose or cirrhosis. This vaccine would be extremely dangerous, although if someone's liver is about to explode* this vaccine may well save their life.

* Not literally, of course, but when they get bad their belly does look like it will explode, and they are in misery.

Comment Re:I'll take a shot... (Score 3, Funny) 350

Also, fusel oils (very common in brown spirits like whiskey and far more rare in clear spirits like vodka) can make hangovers worse.

The very worse hangover I ever had was when I decided to take a sculpture class in college. One of the advantages was learning to weld, and I discovered that if you had a bad hangover and took a cutting torch, turned on the oxygen and breathed deeply the hangover was gone in less than five minutes.

Well, one morning I was so hung over I was still staggering. I went to do my hangover remedy... and you guessed it, I turned the wrong knob. That gave me the mother of all hangovers! The oxygen helped a little after I stopped puking. I felt better after the instructor smoked a joint with me (this was back in the 70s, also known as the "stone" age).

The best hangover remedy won't work any more unless you raise your own chickens, and that's eggnog. Three raw egg yolks in a glass, mixed with milk and a generous amount of sugar and perhaps nutmeg. The yolk of a raw egg contains an enzyme that speeds the breakdown (and come to think of it, might just be an antidote to the vaccine as well). The trouble is that heat, including pasteurization, kills the enzyme. So grocery store eggnog won't work, you need raw yolks, and one of three raw commercial eggs has salmonella. Yeah, no hangover this morning but tomorrow you'll feel worse from the cramps and runs and maybe even be in the hospital.

If you're raising chickens it works well.

Comment Re:Monsanto takes .. (Score 1) 419

Do you have a citation? Because the only instance I could find was a US farmer who planted non-GM corn next to his roundup-ready corn, harvested it, planted the resulting seed corn the next year, and dosed it liberally with roundup to have a free roundup-ready crop the next year. IIRC Monsanto successfully sued.

GM has IP (I hate the term "IP" as it isn't really property). IMO genetics should not be patentable, roundup-ready is a reason. By the time the patent runs out the non=corn grasses will have evolved roundup resistance, so by the time it's public domain, it's worthless.

I wonder if anyone has tried to "engineer" herbicide-resistant crops naturally?

Comment Slashdot needs a K.I.S.S. (Score 1) 7

Yes, it is. At work on XP with IE7 slashdot is a mess, with elements overwriting other elements. I don't blame slashdot... too much, IE7 is a broken piece of shit. However, with the latest Firefox Win7, slashdot's even more broken than IE7! Only half of the slashdot logo is visible, and when you click "account" nothing whatever happens. So I can't change the slashdot password on this machine! Either FireFox isn't WC3 compatible, or slashcode isn't. My money's on slashcode.

Have they not seen Star Trek 3? "The more you over engineer the plumbing, the easier it is to stop up the drain."

If any slashdot coders are reading this, I have a big suggestion. If there's no user-agent string, serve vanilla HTML. And simplify your code! We don't come here to gasp over your 133t coding 5kilz, we come to comment and read others' comments. Make sure it works before adding eye candy.

(Ot bit damn I hate Patch Tuesday)

Comment Re:He's not quite so level-headed (Score 1) 19

...some claim that when they use it themselves they "take ownership" of the word and make it to mean something positive.

Yes. There is no longer a sting to "mick" or "spick" or "dego". I heard more pollack kokes from a guy named Wisinski than anyone.

Comment Re:He's not quite so level-headed (Score 1) 19

I agree, but as to making people responsible, that probably varies by state. I'm pretty sure if you shot someone accidentally you'd be in deep trouble -- when I was first married a friend of my wife hit someone with her car and killed her. The woman was sober, but was still facing manslaughter charges. I seriously doubt an accidental death by firearm would be treated any less harshly. And how could anyone but the privately owned media make an example of someone who accidentally killed themselves?

Comment Bring out your dead! (Score 1) 15

"Reports of my death are greatly exaggerated" (Mark Twain)

Slashdot's biggest problem is that at "news for nerds", we're now vastly outnumbered by normals who think they're nerds because they have an iPad. I don't know of another, better nerd message board.

It isn't dead yet, but K5 died after Rusty started neglecting it; it was a pretty big deal in its time, now it's a ghost town. I see it happening here since Taco left.

Slashdot Top Deals

No man is an island if he's on at least one mailing list.

Working...