But if their bullshit subtracts more than their technical talents add, some of those decidedly more grim options bubble up into the realm of reasonableness, accompanied by their loyal companions: the question of survival, the doubt of mistaking inconsequential nonsense for an existential threat, and the spectre of rocking the boat too hard without a good way to right it.
Good. We are reading from the same book here. Reality must be observed and dealt with, not emotions and feelings.
There is at least 1/3 of the population in a healthy society that is unable to work. This group will be comprised of children and the elderly. Both groups are a net negative on society when viewed from the "immediately useful" category. We can easily discard the elderly as they have already served their purpose and no more use will be had out of them. But that still leaves children. They *might( be valuable in the future, but there is no guarantee.
So, should we let those immediately useless people die from exposure and lack of resources?
From a utilitarian perspective, the answer is yes. The kids that makes it should be stronger than those who didn't. Discarding the elderly will also save a fortune in medical care.
But what does being so utilitarian do to a society (unless good propaganda is used)? Well, who cares what the elderly think? They will be dead soon. So that doesn't matter... but what about the little boy who just loves grandma? What happens to his world view when he sees his grandma being discarded callously?
But let's get to where we are right now. Should a shopkeeper hire more help when their business starts having more customers? The obvious answer is: Yes. But, currently, the shopkeeper can not afford to pay a person enough to actually live. Rent and food cost more than the profits that the shopkeeper is making.
Or to look at it another way: Should a relatively unskilled 9-5 job pay enough to provide food and shelter to a person?
If the pay rate is only enough (which it currently isn't) to maintain one person, what about the third of society that we discussed earlier that can not work?
A modern day Holocaust without the Zyklon B.