Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Flamebait summary much? (Score 1) 445

Khan is a Muslim.

Yes, and so was Dr. Abdus Salam.

Many mainstream Muslim do not consider Ahmadis to be Muslims

So? Many "mainstream Christians" don't consider Mormons to be Christians, yet they are. Many Hasidic Jews don't consider "mainstream Jews" to be real Jews, yet they are. Who determines your faith - you, or other people?

Don't be so naive. When dealing with the external world and categorisation it is not "you" who determines others' label for your religion, but those "other people" who are the majority and make the rules. Those with the biggest metaphorical and physical guns decides who is in the club and who is a heretic.

You may call your religion the one true and holy continuation of Zoroastrianism, but until you are the majority denomination, or the most influential, the rest of the world will consider it to be a loony cult, minor sect, or alternate branch depending on size.

Religious names and categorisation are social constructs, you may even claim to be a Ravenous Bugblatter Beast of Traal, but until the rest of us agree to call you that you're still a human. The point your missing is that in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, "The Land of the Pure", Abdus Salam is not considered to be a Muslim. We both agree to call him Muslim, but that does not change his status in Pakistan. If he was Baha'i or Oriental Christian he would most likely still be written out of local history because they are powerless, minority religions and do not follow the national narrative of a primarily Sunni Islamic nation.

Returning to your attempt at logical argument, likewise most "mainstream Jews" don't consider Christians, or Muslims to be Jewish yet they both claim to be the continuation and reformation of that religion and thus subsume Judaism into their traditions. Ahmadism, Baha'i are examples of reform and syncretic religions. Failed reformations and minor branches are not considered part of the main religion by the main religion; Roman Catholicism still claims primacy as the one true catholic faith with Apostolic Succession. Similarly the Eastern Orthodox and Lutheran churches also claim to be the true Christian faith, none of them consider Mormons to be, and in their jurisdiction they can define what is and isn't Christian by whatever criteria they choose.

Comment Re:Magic (Score 1) 61

they really don't make them like that any more.

the only reason I read the paper is for local news, however even then it is seldom more than 4-6 pages a section and each section is round 4/5 ads.

I don't know where in the world you are, but in some countries there are still some very good newspapers. Germany has some great daily and weekly newspapers/magazines if you can read German such as the Frankfurter Allgemeine (famous for its highbrow nature), Süddeutsche Zeitung, Der Spiegel, and Stern. The Guardian or Telegraph in England are worthwhile reading, and then for me the Irish Times when I'm at home. Ads are not so intrusive in these publications, and normally have reasonable articles and interesting commentary. I remember the Seattle Times being not too bad as well, if a little on the thin side, but stuffed inside it was a bundle of ads thicker than the newspaper.

Comment Re:Magic (Score 4, Insightful) 61

Whats a newspaper?

Being 33 years old, every time I pick something up that I am told is a newpaper, all I get is 1 paragraph of a day old story and 4/5th of a page full of ad's for old lady underwear and flat out scams for gold, homes and used cars... I have given up on finding these fabled papers of news.

You need to read better newspapers. Find yourself a quality broadsheet.

Comment Re:GE/GMO crops (Score 2) 245

A famine has also never occurred in a democratic country.

I think the Irish might have a differing opinion.

That depends on your definition of democracy. During the time of the Famine we were ruled by the landed Anglo-Irish aristocracy, experienced religious and cultural persecution and at the height of the Famine food was exported to England.

This is not meant as a swipe at British of the day or British today, there were of course many decent people who did look after the poor or their tenants, but sadly they were in the minority in Ireland at the time.

Comment Re:12.5% Corporate tax? (Score 2) 626

And people wonder why Ireland has become the basket case of Europe.

The EU is very fond of harmonising the pain to its citizens. It should have a minimum corporate tax rate to ensure that companies pay their dues...

The headline rate might be 12.5%, compared to that of 33.3% for France for example which has complained for a long time about the headline rate; but in reality the effective rate in France can be as low as 8.2% which they actively advertise here.

References can be found here (second graph), here, and here.

What brought down Ireland, and will bring down Spain and the rest of the PIIGS is the private banking debt owed to non-indigenous investors/wholesale banks & the ECB that their taxpayers are being forced to pay for by the ECB. In Ireland's case it was three times its national debt, and continuing to cost more. For Spain it could be worse, possibly €100Bn-300Bn. What turned both countries into basket cases was an unregulated credit fuelled bubble and the idiocy in Germany and the EU commission for confusing a banking problem for a fiscal (i.e. sovereign) problem. The fiscal problem was created by forcing unsustainable levels of debt on the taxpayers of these countries.

Comment Re:Use case differences... (Score 1) 189

Older users are more likely to have a Yahoo address as their primary email, etc.

Real geezers telnet into the server and read their email using MH. If the command line was good enough in 1982, then it is good enough today.

Joking aside, ssh and pine(*) work really well. If the content of the email is heavily using some sort of markup language and graphics it is probably not an email I need or want. On some days I think ssh/pine would be more efficient than a modern GUI-based client. For those unfamiliar with text email clients think of them as twitter without a 140 character limit. ;-) (*) Substitue alpine, mutt, whatever if you prefer.

+1 for pine/alpine. I'm a big fan of that, especially when visiting China where I can still ssh to my old university account and use alpine from there. Plus it's much faster to load than mutt when dealing with huge IMAP inboxes.

Comment Re:BLECK! (Score 3, Informative) 647

What are you talking about? GNOME 3 supports display of multiple non-maximised windows. Have you even used it?

Sort of. But it doesn't really seem to like that. Go to the Dash or Application menu to open a new terminal window, and instead Gnome says - "oh - Terminal! Here's your terminal window right HERE", and just maximizes the one already open. So I have to get Terminal to open a new one for me. Every application works like that. "You don't want ANOTHER application window - use THIS OPEN ONE INSTEAD!"

So Gnome does what it wants, not what I want it to do. And it takes me more mouse click and keystrokes to do anything than it did in Gnome 2. Why?!?

Middle click the terminal button will open a fresh instance, or just use a keyboard shortcut. Vanilla Gnome 3 is terrible, but with Shell Extensions, and Tweak Tools you can have a great DE back. Of course we should not have to install plugins to restore functionality, but I have to say it's a pleasant surprise. I started with FreeBSD in 2001, and tried all the major DEs and WMs (tiling and floating) since then. I'm still waiting for KDE4 to reach the dizzy usabillity heights of KDE3.

Slashdot Top Deals

He has not acquired a fortune; the fortune has acquired him. -- Bion

Working...