Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Let's get this straight (Score 2) 122

Point taken -- how about:

I put a bunch of things in my driveway (think "free" garage sale) along with a sign that says "please take whatever you want". I mistakenly include sexually graphic pictures of my wife in the stuff I've put on display. You find them and take pictures of them with your smartphone, then show them to your friends -- should I be able to charge you with theft (or some other crime?) because you should have known that I didn't intend to give those away?"

Comment Re:Let's get this straight (Score 0) 122

In other words I left my front door unlocked, this doesn't give you the right to go in and snoop around and take my stuff, you CAN however report to me and the newspaper that my door is unlocked.

Isn't the analogy more "If I put a bunch of things in my driveway (think "free" garage sale) along with a sign that said "please take whatever you want", but mistakenly put some of my wife's cherished possessions on display, should I be able to charge you with theft for taking my wife's things?"

Comment Re:Also as a practical matter (Score 1) 1155

You more-or-less have it, but the key is that you can't be compelled to provide witness/evidence against yourself when your liberty is at jeopardy (not sure of the exact legal phrasing).

This leads to situations where a defendant can invoke the Fifth Amendment and not testify to a particular issue at trial, but if he/she is given immunity from prosecution (in one form or another) can be compelled to testify to the same issue (with further refusals to testify met by an open-ended contempt of court charge).

Comment Re:Interesting criminal justice system in the US (Score 1) 149

in the US we have something called the rule of law and due process. that means if the law says you can't get kicked out just because someone thinks you did something bad, you have to be convicted after a trial.

Are you sure about that?

We all know about the recent case of the Canadian man who was suspected of terrorist connections, detained in New York, sent to Syria--through a rendition agreement--tortured, only to find out later it was all a case of mistaken identity and poor information...

Submission + - Patents for Recipes, a.k.a "Therapeutic Foods"? (nytimes.com)

shakah writes: Looks like patent absurdity has spread to recipes (oh, I'm sorry, "therapeutic food" (cough, cough)) — "What is Plumpy’nut? Sound it out, and you get the idea: it’s an edible paste made of peanuts, packed with calories and vitamins, that is specially formulated to renourish starving children. Since its widespread introduction five years ago, it has been credited with significantly lowering mortality rates during famines in Africa."

Comment Re:New Trial? Whatever Happened to Due Process? (Score 1) 280

I've wondered about this myself and have asked a lawyer about it, my understanding is that (as stated on the Wiki page below) the Fifth Amendment only applies to criminal cases (not civil, hence allowing a civil case after criminal case, e.g. O.J. Simpson). Even in criminal cases, again my understanding is that the limitation only applies to a particular sovereign (?), i.e. you could be found not guilty of a crime in state court, but still stand trial for that in federal court. Further, re trying the same civil case over-and-over, my understanding is that anyone can sue anyone, but it does have to pass a few hurdles before actually getting tried (e.g. you probably have to get a lawyer to agree that the case has merit, then have to get a court to accept it along the same lines and agree to run the trial -- my guess is that at some point the court could refuse to accept it, perhaps even penalizing the petitioner with a monetary fine of some sort?).

The wiki page on double jeopardy.

Comment Re:Private Car Cameras (Score 1) 480

Isn't correlation more an indicator of things the insurance company should investigate re establishing a plausible link to causation? Otherwise they'd be chasing blips in data, e.g. if over some period Virgos (Virgoes ?) had half as many accidents as those born under other astrological signs, would you expect insurance companies to incorporate that into their pricing models?

Comment Re:Private Car Cameras (Score 2, Insightful) 480

Why do the slashmongs trot out the "correlation does not imply causation" line as if it's some deep wisdom?

Who cares about causation here? Certainly not the insurance companies, they just want to identify factors correlating with crashes.

Maybe for "slashmongs" like yourself who apparently don't get the (not-so-subtle) difference between causation and correlation?

Insurance companies certainly care about causation, not simply correlation, e.g. if they instituted a "what did you have for breakfast monitor" and found that 20% of their driving population sample ate Brand X cereals before having an accident (aha! correlation!), I doubt they'd offer discounts for households that swore off Brand X cereal.

Comment Re:Oh Noes! (Score 1) 921

The first thing I did after graduating from high school was immediately and gladly stop writing in cursive forever. It's been nearly 30 years, and I've never had a use for it, besides my signature.

About the same for me (though I think I stopped cursive in high school), except for one instance when to make some extra $$ during college I signed up to be a UPS "seasonal driver's helper" (i.e. a runner for a package delivery service). During the "training" they had a form where you were asked to write all the letters of the alphabet in upper- and lower-case (in both print and cursive). I had some serious trouble with cursive capitals, was kind of shocking to me at the time that I had forgotten how to produce 4 or 5 letters.

Comment Re:Put everything in writing (Score 1) 902

We've all come across users with 40 apps open whining their pc is slow

Likewise, we've all encountered clueless IT departments who force apps onto work PCs that suck the life out of them (e.g. anti-virus crap, various drops of MS Kool-Aid the IT dept has bought into, etc.), then on a support call act as if it is the first time anyone has ever complained about the situation.

Comment Re:One idea... (Score 0) 390

My professional wild assed guess is that it cost the industry 1 billion to implement and maybe 1 million a year to maintain/support.

Not sure what your profession is, but if your guesses are as poor as the one above I'd suggest some vocational retraining. Let's say that 20 million lines get ported every year, and 2% fall out of the mainstream (i.e. easy) category -- that's 400k orders in need of manual intervention (on both sides of the port, at that), and each order certainly costs a LEC more than $1.25 to process at that point (figuring a fully-loaded cost for tier-2 support of $20/hr at least).

Slashdot Top Deals

For God's sake, stop researching for a while and begin to think!

Working...