Comment Re:hiroshima... (Score 1) 567
As an American that was an eye opener.
We got the same story in Oz (at least I did in the 70's).
As an American that was an eye opener.
We got the same story in Oz (at least I did in the 70's).
MS XEROX APPLE
MS is like Apple from Bizarro-planet. Everything round is even squared. How appropriate.
I admire his aims, but I don't respect the hypocrisy with which he aims to meet them.
The scientific method is hypocritical? - In what way? I've been a Randi fan for 33yrs, if he has a fault in his approach I would say he could lighten up a bit when it comes to certain fictional works.
As for the rest of your post, ignorance is curable, you seem to be laboring under the misconception that confidence in Science as a reliable way to know the universe equates to a closed mind, this suggest you do not fully comprehend the central role of skepticism in science and would benefit greatly from reading some of Randi's books. I think I can speak for Randi when I say that if someone can pass the JREF tests then the contribution to mankind's knowledge would be worth much more than the prize.
What work?
Hard to believe that the US military in Iraq was trying to detect IDE's with dowsing sticks, but it happened and Randi was instrumental in exposing the scam.
I also credit the man with teaching me the difference between science and woo by explaining the proper role of skepticism in science. You see, I was a teenage fan (18-20) of Uri Geller back in the late seventies, he "fixed" my broken watch by starting at the TV, pretty strong proof, huh. Thing is, Randi's book did in one night what years of HS science could not, taught me the meaning of scientific skepticism and it's role in assessing ANY claim. For this I am eternally grateful to the man and a great admirer of his lifetime of work that not only exposes dangerous scams, but has also given countless people a basic "bullshit detection kit" that can dramatically alter the course of people lives.
I think *honest* forms of placebo can be developed. Placebos don't operate on the rational/analytical levels of the brain
Agree, I think meditation and placebos rely on the same mechanisms in the brain (which can be tricked into releasing very powerful pain killers). When cold, wet and hungry the mere thought of a roast dinner warms me up and stops the uncontrollable shivers. I know the hot meal is imaginary but it still works. I have serious doubts about claims that mind tricks can cure ulcers, warts, etc, these thing often inexplicably cure themselves. Physical pain is a perception, magic works by exploiting the imperfections in human perception. A placebo is part of a Jedi mind trick, it plays the same role as a magician's wand and the monk's navel, it's a distraction.
"faith healing" provides the hope of getting better.
Faith healing provides FALSE hope for REAL money.
Kleeneness is next to Godelness.