Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:A lot of apps use SSL (Score 1) 141

That's not wrong, but it still doesn't explain to me why I, as a user, should trust both application A and site B that have agreed to trust each other with a self-signed certificate. The reason was have the CA model is to introduce a trusted third-party* that can verify for us that everything is on the up-and-up. The user should not be in the position of having to trust unknown parties.

*Yes I know the CA companies have problems. Maybe the model is so broken by nature that it doesn't matter, but it's still true that the self-signed model bypasses it.

Comment Re:A lot of apps use SSL (Score 1) 141

it does not delegate trust to some 3rd party that might screw up and cause things to have be changed, or risk compromise

Instead, the company that issues the self-signed certificate is to be trusted not to screw up? "Just take our certificate, it's fine, trust us".

If Alice and Bob trust each other, this is OK, but what if Bob is bumbling idiot? What about when Alice and Bob, who trust each other, tell Mallory to trust them to trust each other, and Carol mistakenly trusts Mallory?

Comment Re:User Confidence (Score 1) 141

I would not use $RANDOM_SHOPPING_BANKING_APP, but I would visit a bank website using chrome, firefox, or the built-in android browsers. Those three programs, while undoubtedly not flawless, at least have enough respectability and history for me to trust them as well as anything on the internet. Admittedly, that's not much trust, but it's something.

Comment Re:I have now read the article and it is apps misu (Score 1) 141

Presumably you can write them for iOS, and I have no doubt that there are plenty of apps on the AppStore that are playing fast and loose with SSL trust managers.

True fact: I have written Java code to allow for self-signed or any old cert over SSL, or even none. It's not hard to find plenty of sample code. In the course of my employment the code was used for testing only and either not part of a production build or disabled by default in production, but I cannot say what other developers or teams may have done in with my code in their systems.

Why the authors focused on Android and why they felt the need to blame the OS rather than alerting people to cruddy apps, one can only speculate.

Comment linux kernel license fight: ELI5 (Score 1) 946

You have a nice playground called linux, and you ask everyone who comes to play in it to follow your rules, except for parts around the edges where you let other people make their own rules. One of the playground bullies comes along and says you should make the shiniest most fun part of your playground where you ask everyone to follow your rules into an "anyone else can make the rules" area. This bully says you have to do it because he needs to make more friends, and all the people he wants to be friends with play in the shiny part of your playground. You tell the bully that no, he has to make friends by being nice, not by making other people follow his rules, and he calls you a meanie doodoo head and says it's your fault he doesn't have any friends.

Comment ubiquitous (Score 5, Informative) 125

Spreadsheets -- well, Excel really -- are inescapable in business.

I know personally of complex multimillion dollar deals in the oil and gas business involving buying and selling entire refineries and gas pipelines where the numbers were all worked out on a spreadsheet.

The insurance industry lives on the spreadsheets put together by the actuaries.

The only consistent reason I've seen for Excel users will give up their rows and columns and have bespoke software created is when the dataset gets cumbersomely large. A secondary reason is when the kinds of calculations needed can't be cobbled together with Excel's function and macro tools. Even then, it's not unheard of for users to demand summary/aggregate reports and analytics that they then copy the numbers from into their spreadsheet to do their scenarios.

Just keep in mind the next time you hear about big money moving around in some deal -- somewhere someone probably had a pivot table for that.

Slashdot Top Deals

Never test for an error condition you don't know how to handle. -- Steinbach

Working...