Why is it that so many people feel the need to give people some kneejerk economics lesson. Nothing in the original post indicates the person doesn't understand basic economics.
The post I answered to was written by the OP and it indicates he does not in fact understand basic economics. He states he has to sell it at $50 because he can't sell as many as romance novels. This does not make any sense, the price you set your book as to be the one that maximizes the profit margin * books sold equation. The fact that the book took lots of resources to create or targets a niche is irrelevant to this equation.
Sure, writing the book was a sunk cost, but that doesn't make it completely unethical for others to be stealing the product of all the hours he put in writing that book.
I didn't consider the ethical implications, I just talked about how things work in reality: if you price is above people's threshold, they will pirate it.
And the prospect of working several hundred or a thousand hours writing a technical book in a subject where you are a highly educated expert, to make the equivalent of McDonalds wages, is probably not going to encourage people to write books.
If the writing of some books is not economically viable then there is not much we can do beside grants. I still believe that meeting pirates half-way by asking them to donate what they consider fair is a good compromise. After all, even if he wishes people to pay the full price, the money he'd get from pirates paying what they want is money he'd not get at all otherwise.
I didn't specifically make an argument for an economic position,
Well, I am.