Comment Re:Tea (Score 1) 815
Engineering, fundamentally, is "the study of solving problems". It's not, strictly speaking, a science, but an application of science to the real world.
You mentioned China as an example of how good a government/society headed by engineers can be. And I think you're right. Sort of. China is rapidly growing, old Chinese people especially are astonished at how much richer they've become, and China is on track to be the world's new #1 financial center. However, that's pretty much all you can say in China's favor. With regard to human/civil rights, the environment (!), income inequality, working hours/conditions, and basically every intangible aspect of the country, they are the same or worse than the US.
This isn't surprising, given the nature of the engineering mindset. Engineering is the study of solving rational, material problems (the budget and military are two areas of government where engineering would excel). To solve problems as effectively as possible, you must presume absolute license. You must also regard the problem unsentimentally - if you get emotionally involved with it, you'll cloud your judgment and overlook what could be a better solution. The engineers I know all view politics as a series of "problems" waiting to be solved, rather than the conflicts they actually are. They prize "social efficiency" and "harmony" above principles like dignity, individualism, or limited government. They have contempt for anyone who makes it harder for them to do their jobs.
The reason the US is going down the tubes is because we're becoming too much like China, with its "one right way" philosophy. If we're "falling behind" China, it is only because we are both in a race to the bottom. The really important things in life are compassion, trust, respect, dignity, self-direction, and laughter. Beyond having a decent place to live, having enough food to eat, having a little extra to help out needy family and neighbors, and having access to adequate medical care, and basically having a way to secure the important stuff, money can do very little for you. If you have these things (and I'm fully aware that not all Americans do), why does it matter if another person or another nation is wealthier than you? I thought envy was supposed to be a character flaw or something.
If you're so impressed with China, I would suggest you move there. The US used to have a decentralized, individualistic society that would have been pretty much perfect if it had only treated minorities and women better. "Falling behind" and "getting back on top" are important concerns for an empire, not for a republic.
"The search for a material paradise is a flight away from humanity into the sterile nonlife of mechanisms where everything is perfect until it becomes junk. " -- John Taylor Gatto