Comment Re:Who is This Helping? (Score 1) 445
Can you cite any examples where something worked in Firefox 4 but not Firefox 5?
Asking what is broken within *this* particular version is completely missing the point. The point is that someone needs to now go back to their PHB and say that FF is now at new version. Resources for the business need to be taken to examine what changed and how those changed bits will affect the organization's web site. And now this process needs to be repeated every six weeks.
At some point, something major *will* change between versions. In the past, one could look at it and say "ok, version 4.0.1 came out, probably just addressed something minor. Version 5 just came out, must be a major new release, we should look at what changed." The new numbering scheme and release schedule makes it much more time consuming to support Firefox because now every release needs to be examined with the care and attention previously only reserved for major versions.
Well-publicized schedule? New version every 6 weeks.
You missed the word "sane" in my post. Six weeks != sane release schedule for major versions of this software. And yes, the version number incrementing *does* indicate a major version.
You're right again in that people don't want to update their software, that's why Firefox (again like Chrome) does it automatically.
Hmm. Not sure if FF actually does update automatically between major versions, I didn't think so. In any event, major version changes in Firefox have broken add-ons which is a failure for the user.
I don't care if Mozilla releases every 6 weeks, every 3 weeks, or every 3 hours. I do care about supporting the browser on multiple web sites and having to work with developers and users alike. Keeping the version numbers on a major/minor/bug fix scheme actually does work; it wasn't a broken model. This version number bouncing is not for the benefit of the user. Seems to be Mozilla with a case of version number envy; their number is smaller than IE and Chrome and they want to fix it, regardless of whether it benefits anyone.