Comment Re:Good ... (Score 1) 1073
That God doesn't give a shit about my right to file a joint tax return has no bearing on the fact that the United States government doesn't grant rights to the citizenry. That's an inherently un-American way of looking at rights
"Natural rights" may be the American way of looking at rights, but it's also a completely meaningless notion. Rights do not grow on trees. They're not laws of physics or mathematics. (If they were, they couldn't be violated.) Instead rights are a legal notion, and every society and individual has different views on what rights should be recognized.
For instance, you can certainly feel that gays should have the right to marry (as I do), but to say that the right to gay marriage has existed since the dawn of time but just wasn't recognized by the government is meaningless and pointless. You can certainly feel that certain rights should be universal, but there is no sense in pretending that they are.
And if "natural rights" really exist, what are they? Is my "right" not to pay taxes a natural right? Clearly there are people who feel that way. How do you decide in an objective way?