Comment Re:This should be a good thing (Score 1) 754
I hardly think it's a bad thing that people expect you to take part in the effort to take part in the spoils. Imagine you had a farmer who did all the work of plowing the field, sowing seeds, clearing weeds, fertilizing, harvesting, grinding to flour and baking the bread then along comes this guy and says I'm hungry, feed me.
I didn't say (or mean) that expecting people to contribute something is bad, especially not today. But who contributes and what counts as a real contribution are fairly arbitrary. Children in industrialized societies are usually not expected to contribute to their household income today, even though it was the norm for millennia. Likewise, opinions vary wildly over whether being a stay-at-home parent counts as a "job", and often depend on unrelated things like the race and marital status of the mother. Even normal types of wage labor have been/are thought to be unsuitable for various groups of people. (Women can't be doctors! etc.)
In a scarcity-driven society, your example makes sense:
Imagine you had a farmer who did all the work of plowing the field, sowing seeds, clearing weeds, fertilizing, harvesting, grinding to flour and baking the bread then along comes this guy and says I'm hungry, feed me. Maybe you're a good farmer that work long and hard and actually have more bread than you need, but I'd still tell you to pick up a shovel and help out if you want any. Then it's all tractors and machinery so the guy says he doesn't know how to use one, well you still say then learn and help out. Then it's semi-autonomous agriculture drones so the guy says he doesn't know how to maintain one, well you still say then learn and help out. Or do any other work you have.
But the direction it goes in is one where less and less work is required. It takes a lot of people to manually run an entire farm. What if it just doesn't take as many to maintain the drones? Do we shrink the population until there's ~1 person per available job? Or do we do something else, like rotate the work? Imagine only having to work for, say, five years before retirement. Or maybe some people would volunteer to maintain the drones because they find it fulfilling, or maybe drone maintenance comes with extra prestige or privileges beyond a basic standard of living. Or we could wildly expand our definition of what counts as work, so that people writing fanfiction or playing in garage bands are seen as contributing something worthwhile to society. You get the idea.