Comment Re:Culturally Relevant == Irrelevant to CS (Score 1) 612
If, as you've suggested, your whole CS program was a grade-curved culture of relentless competition, then educationally and culturally, that's actually probably not a good thing.
That depends upon your point of view. There's a certain satisfaction and confidence that comes from knowing that your skills are a cut above the rest. Employers also tend to notice these things which is why graduates from highly ranked and competitive programs are more sought after and receive better initial offers from companies hiring them. A graduate of these institutions can also be reasonably well assured that the value of their degree will not be diluted over time by a host of lesser quality graduates who benefited from reduced standards that damaged the reputation of the institution in subsequent years. Now, I do think that students ought to be told up front what will be expected of them, but I don't agree that grading on a curve is a bad thing, either educationally or culturally. Quite the contrary, it's my belief that such programs produce superior graduates who are better equipped to handle the challenges of the working world and that that's worth far more than a high GPA from an average school.