Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Excellent! (Score 4, Interesting) 155

I have nothing to hide, and if this helps catch bad guys, it's still a tremendous invasion of privacy and morally wrong under just about any definition of "moral" you want to use (aside from the "moral = whatever the hell I say it is" definition that seems to be increasingly more prevalent).

If I spend my spare time doing the most boring, non-threatening things imaginable, that is nobody's business but my own. If I spend my spare time doing unusual or asinine things, that's still nobody's business but my own. If I spend my spare time hurting other people and committing crimes that result in damage... then hey, maybe it's time to look into what I'm doing, not before.

Moxie Marlinspike had a great article/journal entry/essay on this topic. I'm not saying he's the next hemmingway, but I'd rather let him explain why we should all have something to hide.

TL;DR - Lots of good things were illegal, once. Big things, like equality (smaller things, too).

Comment Re:I was wondering (Score 5, Interesting) 204

when this would happen. You just had to know that someone would go after them for this. I wonder how it will hold up in court. The bigger question I have is what else will be found during discovery

Well, they'll settle out of court if discovery is an option, and ... IBM isn't just someone. They're looking for ways to mitigate their (other) problems.

No, this is distinctly different than, say ... Facebook going after them. Or Microsoft. Or Apple. Or Samsung.When a company that is already 'losing ground' looks to blame others for their problems, that's a different scenario than a company that isn't threatened pursuing the same lawsuit. The outcome may be the same, which may be all that matters (to some, in theory), but the reasons are completely different. You wouldn't say that a police officer breaking a window to enter a home is the same as a criminal breaking a window to enter your home ... one is looking to profit, the other is looking to protect (again, in theory).

Comment Re:Considering the damages (Score 5, Insightful) 59

Frankly, considering the economic damage he did, the thousands (if not millions) of people he screwed over and caused pain and suffering to, the time wasted to clean up his mess...

18 years is quite small, I'd have no problem with executing him. If people who commit crimes behind computer keyboards were actually punished more often, we might have less of it. As it is, the fraud and abuse online are really more like the wild west than the 21st century.

Economic damage is not a good way to assess penalties. Compare and contrast with Aaron Swartz, Jamie Thomas-Rasset, Kevin Mitnick ...

No, this guy needs to go away because he was breaking the law - not because of how much he broke it.

Comment Not ... exactly. (Score 2) 145

This is just the same approach as Coffee Joulies, which is a former Kickstarter project. I have a bunch of these, they work well. No need for a custom mug.

Well, it's not quite the same as coffee joulies, for a number of reasons.

First, it's integrated/built in.
Second, well ... you won't lose the integrated joulies.
Third... uh ... different name.

Seriously though, this is just an improvement on the thermos. A fancy improvement, and it might even be more effective ... but it's not breaking new ground.

Comment Re:I'll wait for the MSDS/Patent Filing (Score 1) 145

The insulator – which Maxwell won't identify but swears is non-toxic

I think this is a case where it most certainly needs to be disclosed in an MSDS and/or patent filing (though more likely in the MSDS, as the patent filing is allowed to be vague).

MSDS sheets aren't required for consumer products in most places in Canada. They're a workplace 'thing'.

Nevermind the fact you can get an exemption for 'trade secrets'.

Comment Re:The workers are upset (Score 5, Interesting) 841

That Snowden got all the attention, maybe others were planing on blowing some whistles

They've been upset for a long time, about doing secret, unapproved missions. It's a snowden LEAK that make their discontent ... public knowledge.

At least, that had better be the story. Because anything else is just a bunch of rich kids whining that they've been outed (and treated poorly). They weren't slaves, prisoners or compelled to remain.

Comment Re:But what system does he suggest instead? (Score 1) 308

I'm not seeing your point. I don't consider blind obedience to be a good thing. I don't even consider grades (especially not high school grades) to be very important, if that's what you're trying to get at.

I have not said any of that, and I've agreed with you, so I'm not sure what you're asking ... but thank you for sharing your opinion.

Comment Re:I can confirm that (Score 1) 308

Why would you publish your competitive research in industry? I don't see SpaceX at conferences or publishing journal papers. They definitely aren't filing patents, according to Musk.

And besides, as a business owner, I'm not interested in paying for you to write that paper and shepherd it through the publication process. You're a smart guy or gal, I want you working on the next problem so we can all make money, not burnishing your resume with high impact factor pubs. Do it on your own time if you like, but make sure our IP lawyers have a chance to review it before you send the abstract in; you do recall that paper you signed when you hired on.

Ah, by research, you mean peer-reviewed, published research. I see we have the same words but different meanings. I wonder if that could cause misunderstanding.

You might not see the research results immediately, but they are protected (patents and such) and eventually pass into the general knowledge pool.

At least, in theory. Now, if IP laws weren't so restrictive ...

Comment Re:But what system does he suggest instead? (Score 1) 308

Because, if he did, then you had a clear success criteria, and you failed to follow instructions.

And? I would think that anyone with a brain would already realize that's a terrible idea to begin with. I don't consider it a failing to not follow such ridiculous instructions.

Obviously not a great way to evaluate Gym class. Maybe the coach should have counted the number of pushups each person could do. That would be better, right?

No. Obviously not. Quantity is rarely better than quality. On the other hand, if someone says "for every hour you sit in this chair and do nothing, I'll give you $50", and you do it for 8 hours ... well, it's a mind-numbingly stupid waste of time, but hey, quantity counts now, doesn't it?

Comment Re:But what system does he suggest instead? (Score 1) 308

Quantity is not a good indicator of quality, I wouldn't claim otherwise (except in certain circumstances, where it is).

And if you contract for something, and don't receive what you've agreed upon, you've been wronged.

However, if you've agreed to a contract ... and suddenly you're not happy with the terms ... it sounds like the other party isn't the one with the problem. If you had an implicit understanding that was contrary to the explicit contract with a university, and your notion of what you deserve is different from the facts, well ... I feel bad for you. But I don't think you automatically deserve something more.

I don't disagree with your statement about quality, and I think you are correct that a university should train you in that field. I think you're wrong though - If a university is clear in what they are offering, and you don't want that BUT still went ahead with the relationship? Well ... it's a bad relationship, and you can always leave, but you can't blame the university for letting you in.

Comment Re:But what system does he suggest instead? (Score 1) 308

Not if ignoring the instructions gives no advantages, neither to you, nor to someone you want to help, nor the society as a whole.

Exactly. If the whole point is to learn to follow instructions, and you don't follow instructions... well, you fail.

And, lets face it, we're talking about Gym Class, not Medical School, where, incidentally, you also learn to follow instructions (only, they call them procedures).

Slashdot Top Deals

He has not acquired a fortune; the fortune has acquired him. -- Bion

Working...