Comment Re:This isn't Personal USE, this is redistribution (Score 1) 165
As to the advertiser question. The problem becomes one of WHEN I am going to watch the add. If I am watching it I am not watching ANOTHER ad at the same time. I may very well skip the ad, and never pay attention. I may watch the recording a thousand times and never go back to the channel. I may ONLY watch the DVR and skip it every time.
The problem is, that an advertiser pays for an event. And the event it paid for, is not what you are doing when it is dvr'd. It is definitely not the same when it is "on-demand".
This of course doesn't apply to Planters Peanuts during the World Series of Poker.