Comment Hysteria vs demonstrated risk (Score 1) 332
I'm a surgeon, and often work long hours. Lots of my colleague do too. I have always only needed 4-5 hours of sleep per night - just wake up after 5 hours, even without an alarm. Many of my surgical partners are the same, but just not as much. Surgery seems to attract people who tend not to need much sleep, and are driven.
I have never heard of a surgeon, nor seen, a mistake, or poor outcome, due to someone being tired
If someone can show a higher complication rate for surgeon, who are sleepy, then I'd consider the above proposal, otherwise it's just over reactionary crap.
I've had plenty of times like the above "scenario" where I've been a bit tired. No mistakes, no complications, no extra time - everything turned out perfectly. If I'm tired, then I'll do something about it. I've delayed 2 cases until the next day in 5 years (thats' 2 cases out of 1750 cases because of being tired).
Let's see some data, as opposed to truck driver, or pilot studies - 'cause surgery isn't anything like those jobs.