Comment Depends on the office noise level... (Score 1) 262
If stretching out your arms will hit two cow-orkers, several of them are talking on the phone, or to each other... and if you've got low-walled or no cubicles (forget about real walls), then my productivity is about as high as it would be if you were slapping me in the face every few seconds, without some kind of masking sounds pumped-in to mask the distractions. Muzak-style is fine, but headphones are okay if your office doesn't have the foresight to install that.
Headphones with no audio playing is okay, as they function like earplugs. Music is usually good, but need to vary the selection or boredom sets in. "Relax and Sleep" Android white noise generator app helps a lot on days when neither one suits you.
When I started using headphones all-day at my last company, they spread like an infection. You could see the ring of headphones expanding out from the epicenter of my desk, week after week. Might have been partly because neighboring office meerkats saw my productivity going way, way up when I started. Not sure how much it helped any others', though.