Comment Re:Decline? Huh (Score 1) 119
Wow, a whole 2% annual growth, that's just mind-blowing. Definitive proof that stealing music doesn't hurt anyone.
2% growth definitively debunks the claim is causing decline in revenues because the decline is nonexistant, despite so many factors that would lead one to expect decline even if there were no piracy whatsoever. That's the whole point. Your "stealing music doesn't hurt anyone" argument was never made - it is a strawman argument.
Say, what do you sell for a living? Cars? I'm one of the people that's been stealing cars off your lot. You're losing money? Bullshit! You're insured! And your cars suck anyway! And you're an asshole!
Baloroth did not say that stealing does not cause bereavement. He did not say that insurance makes theft or any other harmful actions become victimless. He did not assert that either theft or copyright infringement is fair because of music sucking or the exploited being assholes.
Sorry folks, here in Canada, my band is postponing our annual nationwide tour because larger venues are doing less and less live music in favour of DJ bullshit (which many of them play pirated music) so we're now competing with Juno award winners for 200-500 seat venues. We now have to book a year in advance to get the key venues to make the tour profitable.
Less scrupulous DJs cheat musicians out of royalties and their cheating puts you at a disadvantage as a secondary effect and causes all sorts of trouble for you. I get that. It sucks. We get it. This perspective is insightful but it really doesn't have much bearing on what you're trying to say (namely, that Baloroth does not know what the fuck he's talking about, as you put it). I suppose you could just be leading up to this:
So you'll have to forgive me as I break ranks with other musicians who have placated piracy advocates. We're just being polite because our reputations require it. I've done over 100,000 miles of touring, I've seen members of hit bands looking for odds jobs because their back catalog doesn't sell, I've seen the empty floors at Sony's NYC offices, I know excellent producers that are hopelessly in debt, and I know musicians that kick the shit out of current pop stars but can't get 1/10th the record deal they could have in the 80's.
This whole paragraph is built around blatantly implying that Baloroth [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominum]is a piracy advocate[/url]. He might well be, but there is no indication that he is, and it has no bearing on the strength of his argument.
You do not know what the fuck you're talking about. No matter how you interpret the infinitesimal amount of information you have on the matter, your advocacy of piracy directly prevents me from doing what I love and providing for other talented musicians. I'm not going to pretend I can stop you from pirating music, but please shut the fuck up.
Here we go again. GP did not advocate piracy at all. Not even once. Anti-piracy sceptics and piracy advocates are not the same thing at all. You need to get that chip off your shoulder and you will find life much more bearable.