Comment Re:"Big" question? (Score 1) 229
most adults do not really believe the tenets of any major religion anyway.
Of course not. The question is, do most adults believe some of the tenets?
That depends profoundly on what you mean. Most religious people, most of the time, do not permit their religion to get in the way of their common sense or their common decency. When questioned on a point of religious belief, they will reliably respond according to their understanding of doctrine
An example: Martyrdom. We know from the lives of the saints, and from the acts of certain modern-day counterparts, that there are those who put their faith in God ahead of their self-preservation, placing themselves in harm's way in the service of faith. We know, also, that only a tiny minority of religionists do this
This is what people mean when they question whether religionists really do believe what they say they do. Most of the time, when we say "belief", we mean something that we are willing to rely upon: if you believe it is cold, you do not wear shorts; if you believe that Jane does not love you, you do not propose marriage to her. Your belief is detectable in your actions which rely upon it, which are explained by it.
Dennett presents the notion of "believing in belief" -- the idea that many people think that religious belief is a good thing, a thing to be desired, indeed one which you should pretend to, or "fake it until you make it". People who believe in belief can be expected to say they believe religious claims, but not to actually rely on them. This seems to be a cogent explanation of the way that most "religious" people actually deal with the real world.