That's pretty fair, if a bit complicated. But even if the jury and judge came to the decision that *every* person who got their copy of the song from her would have bought it if she personally hadn't been seeding it and decided to make her penalty 99 cents for every song she seeded times the number of uploads, that would still be far more reasonable than the bullshit they handed her.
Even if we take the "low" fine of $54,000, that's $2,250 per song. So what, she uploaded each song over 2000 times? What crap. I understand that some of the fine is more than just compensation, it's also deterrent, but shit, man that's just ridiculous.
On the bright side, I have a habit of downloading something "illegally" every time I let something like this get under my skin, so, off to the torrentz!