Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:When jobs are scarce, this happens (Score 1) 330

I think you mean "if you are a university, you can pay the coaches more money and hire more adjuncts instead of tenure track faculty." There is a difference between a university wanting money to support staff, get new equipment, etc, and a company that is accountable to shareholders. Big difference. Look at non-profit vs. for-profit universities, for a start.

Comment Brain or nervous system? (Score 0) 272

Sorry folks, you can't say from a purely behavioral study what "the brain" is doing. Even if you take a totally materialist stance (as opposed to dualism) you still can't. You must point to a brain region that lights up (or is damaged), or event related potentials (a type of EEG analysis) to talk about what the brain is doing. In this case, it is entirely possible that other parts of the nervous system are influencing the biases reported in TFA and the cited articles. The peripheral nervous system is important for behavioral and emotional processes too. For example, paralyzed patients experience dampened affect, among other things.

As a neuroscientist I'm scared that the perception of my field will be hurt by crappy pop neuroscience, much like how psychology was hurt by pop psychology in the 90s (and is still recovering).

Comment Re:AP Tests (Score 1) 913

AP = advanced placement. You take a harder version of a given subject, and if you pass an exam, you get credit for that course in college. It is really equivalent to an IB course or a British A-Level (or whatever they are calling them now?). However, high school teachers tend to overwork the students in these courses (which is why I think they are terrible college prep, even though you learn the material) so it is very difficult to take more than three or so per year. So students who are from a remotely decent school district will probably take a few of these, which comes out to being similar to doing IB courses and then going to university. A big problem in the states is that we do have degrees in areas that wouldn't normally require university degrees in Europe (Childhood development = preschool teachers, accountants, and so on). There would be less need for gen eds if one limited US universities to only serious academic majors. Having said this, learning philosophy from someone who has a doctorate and knows the material exceptionally well is probably a better experience than learning it from a high school teacher (whether in a US AP course or a more rigorous European high school).

Comment Re:Good luck. You'll need it. (Score 1) 913

Right, because all of the people who put men on the moon, are trying to fix the economy, and cure diseases, are just academics who don't get anything done.

You mean the fundamental flaw in Ph.D programs is to produce more academics, rather than focusing on getting them out in the world to get things done. Undergraduate programs (especially at the gen ed level) skim the surface. If anything, a lot of fields (especially engineering and CS) try to weed out students, not push them all towards academia.

Comment Re:No offense intended, but... (Score 1) 913

Does a barber or a janitor understand the difference between correlation and causation? Do they understand what the word "logic" really means? Do they understand basic economics? Most of them probably don't. And I wouldn't be surprised someone who is a good programmer but lacks a well rounded education is much better than his barber or her janitor.

Comment Re:No I am not (Score 1) 913

The problem with "just reading" is that it helps to have someone who is an expert explain things to you in more detail, or to be there to answer your questions. Writing about the stuff really makes you think about it an synthesize it more. It is sort of like the difference between reading proofs of calculus without having actually taken a derivative.

Slashdot Top Deals

He has not acquired a fortune; the fortune has acquired him. -- Bion

Working...