Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:It couldn't be more obvious (Score 1) 503

Stalinism, fascism, and all hierarchical authority is right wing, by definition. Left wingers, the people have no voice in government anywhere in the world, have more anarchistic tendencies that seek a stateless society where people live by cooperation and self discipline instead of coercion.

Well, yes and no. Leftists support a position of empowerment for ordinary citizens. This is different from Libertarianism because people on the left would support, for instance, unionization over corporate control, environmental initiatives over industrial interests, and public healthcare over employer-provided insurance.

Comment Re:If Americans cannot compete with non Americans. (Score 1) 795

Most H1Bs *are* from developing nations like India and China. $150k, invested wisely, would provide acomfortable living in the countryside of such a nation for life. That is, of course, beside the point; regardless of whether he retires on the money or spends it on hookers and blow, as long as its spent in his home country it's a net loss to the local community.

Comment Re:Here here! Well said. (Score 1) 795

Do I like this? No. But I'm having a hard time arguing against the math.

Well it's not hard to do.. After all, these companies still find outsourcing too expensive or too low in quality, so they ask the government to make it artificially cheaper for them to hire foreign employees that have no bargaining rights. The solution would be to disallow this, forcing them to either pay market price for workers or move their operations overseas. I'm pretty confident based on some of the outsourced nightmares I've encountered that most companies would get burned once or twice on outsourcing, then decide to pay market price for workers.

As an aside, I would be happy to have some sort of citizenship track visa that allowed skilled workers to live and work in the US, pay US taxes, and not be deported merely because of loss of employment, thus being able to negotiate wages on the same playing field.

Comment Re:If Americans cannot compete with non Americans. (Score 4, Informative) 795

Otherwise known as a fair market wage?

Whoever's writing as Cringly is just being racist here. There's no moral wrong when a non-American gets an "American job", whether through immigraiton or offshoring. Everyone deserves to compete for any job, without prefernce given by race or place of birth.

Sure, I'd personally like to see all the cool developer jobs reserved for somewhat overweight middle-aged white guys, but that's because I'm a greedy bastard, not because it would be some kind of moral virtue!

The problem is that it puts a net drain on the local market, both in terms of skilled workers and in terms of money. An H1-B takes a low paying job that would traditionally go to an entry-level local worker, works for several years, and returns home with enough money live on comfortably for the rest of his life due to the exchange rate. This means that the local entry-level worker can't find a job and becomes disenfranchised, and a total loss of ~50k * 3 yr = $150k is permanently removed from the local economy. Now maybe this is not ethically wrong, but it is not in the best interests of the local economy or the national economy.

Comment Re:School is worthless... (Score 1) 309

Alright, *your* words, from *your* comment that *you* linked to:

- yes, those are my words, I stand by them and never changed them.

Obviously you went into one of those public schools, because those words are twisted in your irrational mind into something that they are not.

You are building a strawman and then are taking it down, is that what they taught you? Because I never said I am against education, I said I am against public funding for all schools, I am against public schools, I am against all public funding for anything and everything.

Again, this means education would actually be affordable, cheap and of high quality, just like the cheapest mobile phones today, that are sold in the market by businesses that do it for profit.

So what is your problem, lack of logic or lack of argument?

Right, you're in favor of education for people who can afford it. Hence money = freedom. You're an anarcho-capitalist, an idiot, and an overall terrible human being. Please go to Somalia where the government will leave you alone, and leave the civilized world to civilized people.

Comment Re:School is worthless... (Score 1) 309

Your anarcho-capitalist vision of what "freedom" means is essentially "might makes right"

- no, the market is all people making voluntary decisions on every day basis about their own lives. What business to participate in, what product to buy, what to avoid, etc. This has nothing to do with probably criminal behavior that you are talking about.

You are so wrong when you think I am talking about "removing education", it's insane how wrong you are. Education is very important, I am talking about making sure that it stays relevant, that it is not inflated into nothingness like every other bubble that government creates with fake money and ideas of 'fairness' or 'free whatever'.

I wonder, you think that 'freedom' is a 'weasel word', I wonder who 'educated' you this way? Freedom is the concept that USA was founded upon, it's the concept that you are a free individual to run your life to the best of your abilities, without somebody directing and controlling you.

Of-course this doesn't mean you should be hurting people in the process, but to me it seems you are not against the idea of hurting people, as long as it is the government that does it.

Alright, *your* words, from *your* comment that *you* linked to:

Personally I am against all public schools completely

Changing your position every time someone calls you on something might work against some people, but it doesn't make you right. In fact, it just makes you more of a douchebag. And for the record, I was once a card-carrying member of the Libertarian Party. Unlike libtards such as yourself, however, I grew up and realized that money is not a very good indicator of the value of a person.

Comment Re:School is worthless... (Score 2) 309

tell me how it helps people to have to go $60k into debt to get a degree required for the kind of job that would provide a living wage

- I never said it helps, quite the opposite, read this comment, do you think I believe it helps?

Of-course when something is 'free' the quality also suffers, even when it's just highschool (or the wasted 'educational' process before it).

Or how providing higher education is the same thing as murder?

- you missed your favorite word in that sentence: free. A government that is big enough to "give" you "free" anything, including "free" education, is the gov't that destroys every individual freedom in the process.

You know, they provide 'free' food (food you don't have to pay for if you are receiving it) in prisons, right?

I know I shouldn't feed the trolls, but...

"Freedom", in the sense you're using, is completely meaningless. Your anarcho-capitalist vision of what "freedom" means is essentially "might makes right". Individual freedom to do anything within your means has no value if you have no means. Your goal of removing education, one of the few equalizers we have in society, is just an attempt to create an aristocracy. The fact that you use weasel words like "Freedom" to convey this makes it no less true, nor does it make it any more justified in pursuing that goal.

Comment Re:School is worthless... (Score 2) 309

Do you have a better plan? I mean, I have a better plan: free tuition for anyone who can pass the entrance exams. It would be much cheaper than our current system of government-backed loans, but that's not really the point, is it? The issue here is to ensure that you create a class of indentured servants who have no choice but to pay the rest of their lives for the education they received in their 20's.

Slashdot Top Deals

2.4 statute miles of surgical tubing at Yale U. = 1 I.V.League

Working...