Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop


Forgot your password?

Submission + - Is someone selling 5 Star book reviews?

An anonymous reader writes: Is someone selling 5 Star book reviews?

I noticed a book reviewer named "Midwest Book Review" had several 5 Star book reviews, each of which looked liked book blurbs, not reviews. I then checked out the reviewer at: O/ref=cm_cr_auth/102-4466102-9848954

I wrote the following:

Comments:Dear Amazon,
> I love the customer review feature of
> I think a reviewer named "Midwest Book Review" may be abusing the
review process.
> It appears they have 31,106 book reviews on your site. The first
200 reviews I looked at all had Five Star ratings. (I only looked
at the first 200 book reviews.)
> I have no idea what's going on here, but the sample of reviews I
read seem more like book promotion blurbs than reviews. I'm
wondering if they are selling Five Star reviews to authors.
> See
> Any abuse of the review process severly weakens my
faith in the review process, which I rely on to make good choices.
> I hope you will investigate this matter and find out if the review
process is being abused.
> Thanks.

Amazon responded:

Thank you for contacting

We appreciate that you took the time to write to us about this
issue. I have looked into this situation and found that the reviews
posted by Midwest Book Reviewer do not fall outside of our review
guidelines. While we do not condone selling positive book reviews,
we have no way of showing that this is what is happening in this
case and cannot take any action.

We thank you for your interest in our customer reviews. Comments
such as yours help us improve our service and are always
appreciated. Let us know if you have any other concerns.

Please let us know if this e-mail resolved your question:


I am not claiming Midwest Book Review (
is doing anything wrong. I could not look through all 31,000+ reviews to see if they are all 5 star reviews. The reviews may be honest appraisals. It does, however, look suspicious to me.

"Unibus timeout fatal trap program lost sorry" - An error message printed by DEC's RSTS operating system for the PDP-11