Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive


Forgot your password?
The Media

Submission + - BS Detection for Internet Journalists 1

Hugh Pickens writes writes: "When a frustrated computer programmer created a fake website and press release about a study showing Internet Explorer users are not as smart as people who used other browsers, major media organizations fell for the hoax. How could this embarrassment--and an instance of misinforming the public--have been avoided? Jennifer Dorroh writes about the steps every internet journalist should take for verifying information found on the web: Start with a Whois lookup on the domain to see who has registered the url. Then check the Internet archive to get a feel for the overall history of the site. Check the site's Google PageRank. If the page rank is high, that probably means credible sites have been linking to it. Run blog and news searches to see if the person, topic or company has been talked about before. "Check names. Do they have a personal history? Is the name drawn from history or literature," writes Dorroh. "Hoaxers often like to be clever by giving themselves historical names." Finally when a news organization does decide to report something that isn't 100 percent confirmed, they should make it very clear that "this is what we know, this is what we don't know, this hasn't been confirmed," says Craig Silverman, editorial director of and editor and author of Regret the Error. "It's important to be brave and transparent about what you don't have.""
This discussion was created for logged-in users only, but now has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

BS Detection for Internet Journalists

Comments Filter:
  • Where is the truth? The real truth is IE is still bundled with Microsoft's OS, Which is major news. This reads more like Women's Magazine lies. The reason it was reported so much, is people it felt true, or the arrogance in people made it feel true. There have been better browsers than IE for years, and they are free, why would anyone use IE? I know the reasons; I suspect you do too, and its not because they are stupid. Less competent with a computer maybe...doesn't stop them being a rocket scientist though

All science is either physics or stamp collecting. -- Ernest Rutherford