Orson Scott Card on Games, 21 Years Ago 121
MilenCent writes "Long long ago, Orson Scott Card wrote a game opinion column for Compute! Magazine. In the November 1983 issue, he had some interesting things to say about the essential ingredients of a great game, all arguably still important today. He picked out one company that, at the time, consistently excelled in most of these areas--try to guess which one! Additional commentary over at Curmudgeon Gamer."
EA... (Score:4, Insightful)
Madden 2015 (Score:3, Insightful)
lol
Other company mission statements from 1983:
Mac: Our computers must run everyone's software and be affordable.
Microsoft: By 2006, all bugs and security holes must be eliminated. Also, we will open source everything.
FCC: By 2006, ABC will be required to show boobs at the top of every hour, all day long. Also, Howard Stern will host the Oscars.
Fine, so EA didn't always suck, but ... (Score:4, Insightful)
Now they've evloved into more of a video game sweat shop than anything else. The games they publish that are still good are designed and written by third partys.
Reading this article really hightens my sense of loss for one of the great companies of my generation.
EA need to read this (Score:2, Insightful)
Clearly that one was forgotten about long ago, these days its just endless sequels each containing fewer differences than the last. Originality was forgotten about long ago in favour of squeezing every last dollar out of a 'franchise'.
Sports games killed them (Score:3, Insightful)
Then again, Origin was already half-dead. Starting with Ultima 7 they did just what Card lambasted in his article: "I have little patience with games that play me, forcing me to follow only one possible track or learn one mechanical skill if I hope to win." I remember I lost my first attempt at Ultima 7 because I started wandering around and hit the story elements out of order. U7 part 2 fixed that: you simply couldn't wander beyond the nearby area until you had completed the story-line there. A double-whammy for Ultima 8 which was both strictly linear and required a lame jumping skill to win. Even the beautiful Ultima 9 was nastily linear for the first half of the game, opening up only when you got a control of the ship.
Origin was already in trouble. EA just finished the job.
A reference to computer games! (Score:5, Insightful)
Hurrah! Evidence of the existence of the computer games industry. It's not something you see often on here. Not the video game industry, the computer game industry: The one that almost all of the major players in the current game industry were borne out of.
Video game crash in the U.S? Irrelevant...computer games never stopped. They went on from strength to strength via the C64, ST, Amiga, and then the PC (when it's CPU speed finally came up to scratch).
It's getting harder and harder these days to find any sort of real history of games due to revisionists re-writing everything and putting such huge importance on video games, Atari, and Nintendo.
Let's have more articles like this.
Re:Today, graphics come first, gameplay second. (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Today, graphics come first, gameplay second. (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:End Game (Score:3, Insightful)
No offense intended to Mr. Card, as if it wasn't for Ender's Game I may not have decided to become a game designer. But there is a big difference between ivory tower thinking about great gaming and the actual down and dirty process of making them.
Re:EA... (Score:1, Insightful)
Re:Random Card theories (Score:2, Insightful)
The problem is that Card is not politically correct and holds some opinions that are not well liked by some people, particularly about homosexuals. Card is also very religious, which makes him a threat to some people. I think much of the criticism against him has to do with people who are threatened by his politics, so they attack his writing. Politically, he is pretty close to former Senator Zell Miller - both claim to be Democrats, but are big fans of the current president.