Journal metroid composite's Journal: Highest Posts per Day boards on the Internet? 37
GameFAQs purges topics if they haven't been posted in for a given amount of time (for most larger boards about a day; but the purge only happens once a day). Hard to get posts per day for that reason...at least as far as individual boards go.
Taken at 9/24/2003 19:09:29
topic=10239326
message=106369223
Individual boards: taken at 19:06 GameFAQs time
LUE:2381; 36680
RI:1028; 26798
CE: 1735; 17528
And a few a bit later:
SC2003: 626; 17194, 9/24 7:12PM
PotD: 929; 17476, 9/24 7:15PM
IGN Doesn't seem to purge...or maybe they purge every two years or something; hard to tell. Fortunately they tell total posts.
Total Messages: 60,807,042 (38,322 posted today) Taken at 7:19pm IGN time.
Vestibule: 371,251; 5,689,766; 7:19pm
GCN General Board: 106,834; 2,199,845; 7:25pm
XBox General Board: 77,941; 1,280,921; 7:27pm
The thing to do is to check back later, and then estimate Posts per Day (PpD). Obviously post raw post counts between sites don't tell much due to varying purge rate; and moderated messages are not insignificant for some boards. My estimation just by pressing the refresh button is that LUE is larger than the Vestibule, but not by too large of a factor.
Why am I doing this? Scientific curiosity... Cataloguing the Internet... something like that. If anyone is reading this, can you direct me to other particularly large boards (or suggest a way to estimate the size of Slashdot...)?
more data on the subject (Score:1)
Total Messages: 60,855,635 (36,559 posted today)
GCN General: 106,994 2,202,685 7:22pm
XBox General: 78,100 1,283,368 7:23pm
GameFAQs
topic=10255077
message=106555475
Post
LUE: 2281 36635 9/25 7:22PM
CE: 1723 18060 9/25 7:22PM
RI: 1011 25618 9/25 7:22PM
PotD: 895 15701 9/25 7:22PM
SC2003: 684 17424 9/25 7:25PM
Size of Slashdot found (Score:1)
Wednesday: 9435 posts
Tuesday: 7049 posts
Monday 7431 posts
Actually somewhat larger than I expected; I'm pleasantly surprised. Though, my estimate of LUE is still around 20,000 PpD.
Data analysis (Score:1)
PpD = Posts per Day
(Copy this into a plain text editor to get things to line up, and replace the "z" with "."
Day 3 of data taking (Score:1)
GameFAQs: Posted: 9/26/2003 7:10:15 PM
topic=10270106
message=106725070
LUE 2188; 35658, 9/26 7:10PM
PotD: 883; 15413, 9/26 7:10PM
RI: 851; 24079, 9/26 7:10PM
CE: 1655; 17709, 9/26 7:10PM
SC2003: 683; 18116, 9/26 7:16PM
IGN: Total Messages: 60,898,
Forgot Penny Arcade (Score:1)
697 60334
Total posts:
179831
I'm...skeptical about this one. Might have a purge rate, but I suspect it's just plain new.
Data analysis of most recent set (Score:1)
GameFAQs: 169595
IGN: 43011
Main(Slashdot): 7437
LUE: 17739
Vestibule: 11269
RI: 11200
CE: 5640
SC2003: 5056
PotD: 4528
GCN Genrl: 2886
XBX Genrl: 1818
Fourth day worth of stats (Score:1)
meant to do plain text (Score:1)
message=106935563
Posted: 9/27/2003 7:28:10 PM
LUE: 2576; 39092
CE: 1664; 17675
RI: 926; 26153
PotD: 904; 15688
SC2003: 717; 19043
Askmen.com
Daily Posts: 2165 Total Posts: 1093651
Webcomics (10:30 by now)
Posts: 654,981
Newgrounds
General: 1,015,614
Straight Dope
Threads: 207,512, Posts: 3,936,517
GenMay (10:33 by now)
205,930 threads in total | 4,837,528 posts in total
General Mayhem: 4184596; 170584
Hard Forum
282,091 threads in total | 2,657,427 posts in total
Penny Arcade:
185943
SE++: 62193
The data analysis (Score:1)
data part...5 (Score:1)
9/28 7:13PM
topic=10309735
message=107159555
LUE: 3083, 47359
CE: 1294, 13798
RI: 1008, 27161
PotD: 976, 15749
SC2003: 522, 15831 9/28 7:15PM
And the analysis (Score:1)
GameFAQs: 223992
IGN: 50002
Gen Mayhem: 14995
Hard Forum: 3417
StraightDope: 3236
Webcomics: 3080
Penny Arcade:
Re:And the analysis (Score:1)
Early data today. (Score:1)
GameFAQs:
topic=10325673&message=107342733
LUE: 2786; 43510 9/29 6:39PM
CE: 1856; 19539
RI: 891; 25458
PotD: 946; 15781
SC2003: 716;18914 9/29 6:40PM
Webcomic
P= 1098122
Newgrounds: 1,349,743
P= 1404268
Straight Dope (9:50)
P= 4046816
GenMay: 207,068 threads in total | 4,868,745 posts in total
General Mayhem 4211605; 171471
P= 4943807
Hard Forum: 282,906 threads in total | 2,664,528 posts in total
P=1025323182
Penny Arcade: 275580
P=1022523
Rotte
Missing Penny Arcade (Score:1)
Whenever I have p= or d= incidentally, it's the marked message url, which I'm finding more accurate.
GameFAQs:
topic=10343637
message=107551122
LUE: 2738; 42190
CE: 1031; 11489 9/30 7:48PM
RI: 862; 23940
PotD: 987; 17263
SC2003: 453; 13750
Webcomics: Posts: 664,387
p=1101524
Genmay
Penny Arcade back up (Score:1)
Results for yesterday (Score:1)
IGN: 46892
General Mayhem 16226
Webcomics 10360 (Suspected typo on my part. It's consistent from day to day at about 3000...)
Slasdot 9243 (probably an underestimate; took samples too late for the first one).
Rotten Tomatoes: 8035
Penny Arcade: 6240
StraightDope 3607 (and this confirms it as not too large. I'll stop recording it probably).
Newgrounds 2816 (it's getting the boot)
LUE: 22294
General Mayhem (GenMay): 13688
Vestibule (IGN): 12250
RI: 12078
CE: 6711
SC2003: 5938
PotD: 5033
Post a Link (Fark): 3
Forgot slashdot again (Score:1)
And today's analysis (Score:1)
GameFAQs: 208,389
IGN: 51,272
GenMay: 19,580
Slashdot: 9,321
Rotten Tomatoes: 8,550
Penny Arcade: 4,321 (did get back up eventually, though slow day I guess)
Webcomics: 3,402 (yeah, just a glitch in my recording process)
LUE: 21482
General Mayhem: 16898
Ve
The data for tonight (Score:1)
LUE: 2674 43988 10/01 7:46PM
CE: 1663 17297
RI: 965 24969
PotD: 996 17812
SC2003: 666 17225 7:46PM
topic=10359793
message=107740227
Webcomics:
Threads: 19,043, Posts: 667,329
p=1104558
Genmay: 208,440 threads in total | 4
And the data analysis (Score:1)
GameFAQs: 189,105
Go-Gaia: 97,176 (although their "artilce" counter claims 141153)
IGN: 46,871
GenMay: 18,378
Slashdot: 10,069
Rotten Tomatoes: 7,961
Soompi: 7,177
Penny Arcade: 6,441
Nick: 5,692 (a pure estimate--attempt to salvage corrupted data)
Team
Data number whatever (Score:1)
LUE: 2520; 41610 10/02 7:15PM
CE: 1664; 17304
RI: 971; 25366
PotD: 1018; 18182
SC2003: 676; 17927
topic=10374909
message=107919387
Genmay: 209,052 threads in total | 4,924,937 posts in total
General Mayhem: 4259714 173026
d=5000003
Penny-arcade:
p=1037628
RottenTomatoes:
General Discussion: 1198602 70726
d=3017415
IGN: Total Messages: 61,187,495 (37,124 posted today)
Vest: 378,542 5,797,190 7:25pm
p=46099510
Slashdot:
p=7120351
Soompi: Our members ha
Here's Go-Gaia (Score:1)
Chatterbox: 18312 1075790
p=7520314
9:48 (12:48)
I'll post the analysis later.
The data analysis (Score:1)
Go-gaia: 88,452 (they had tons of server maintenance yesterday, so I had to grab this late, though this time they gained more than post total differences, which suggests purge fluctuations like Penny-Arcade. No scientific explanation that I know of)
IGN: 46,536
GenMay: 18,238
Slashdot: 9,938
Soompi: 7,218
RottenTomatoes: 6,901
PennyArcade: 4,343
Team XBox: 3,649 (dropped)
Nickelodeon: 1,015 (...wow, didn't expect 5,000, but something's odd here)
LUE: 20644
General Mayhem: 15254
Vestiblue (IGN): 1279
Attempt to salvage data (Score:1)
LUE: 1693; 30560 10/04 9:11AM
CE: 1290; 13386
RI: 671; 19791
PotD: 777; 14077
SC2003: 490; 16122
topic=10390151
message=108096723
GemMay:
d=5023967
Penny Arcade:
p=1044989
RottenTomatoes:
d=
Re:Attempt to salvage data (Score:1)
And salvaged analysis...kinda (Score:1)
GameFAQs: 177,336
Go-gaia: 71,696
IGN: 45,136
GenMay: 23,964
EBay: 22,702
ForumPlanet: 12,453
Slashdot: 9,682
PennyArcade:
Data (yet another try) (Score:1)
topic=10408730
message=108297460
LUE: 2541; 41456 10/04 7:29PM
CE: 1765; 17435
RI: 1021; 25253
PotD: 894; 15827
SC2003: 567; 17978
GenMay: 210,231 threads in total | 4,957,262 posts in total
General Mayhem: 4287254 173923
d=5032323
Penny Arcade:
p=1047764
Rotten Tomatoes:
General Discussion: 1202826 70969
d=3030466
IGN: Total Messages: 61,275,293 (32,980 posted today)
Vestibule: 380,189 5,823,504 7:35pm
p=46186975
Slashdot:
p=713
More data part whatever (Score:1)
CE: 1938; 18138
RI: 1052; 25917
PotD: 872; 13809
SC2003: 572; 18150 10/05 7:20PM
topic=10428190
message=108508065
GenMay: 210,790 threads in total | 4,972,225 posts in total
General Mayhem: 4300239 174359
d=5047314
Penny Arcade
p=1053575
Rotten Tomatoes:
General D: 1205383 71116
d=3015586
IGN: Total Messages: 61,328,372 (40,684 posted today)
Vestibule: 381,161 5,841,121 7:28pm
p=46239713
Slashdot:
p=7140536
Soompi: Our members have made a total of 1,138,857 posts
p=2572217
Nick:
tID=1
more data without analysis (Score:1)
And some mini-analysis (Score:1)
GameFAQs 205 k
Go-Gaia: 125 k (Note: they've been offline for the past two days so this is based
off the bad day's data)
IGN: 50 k
EBay: 20 k
General Mayhem: 15 k
ForumPlanet: 10.5 k
Soompi: 9 k (O_O that's a jump)
TechTV: 8 k (better than I hoped)
Slashdot: 6.5 k (slows down on weekends)
Rotten Tomatoes: 6.5 k
Penny Arcade: 6 k
Nickelodeon: 5.5 k
UltimateWedding: 3k (Yeah...
More data (Score:1)
plain text...again -_- (Score:1)
I'm only entering in selected parts of this to the spreadsheet; too much stuff. Probably done testing on some of the early boards now.
LUE: 2567; 37945 10/07 7:19PM
CE: 1678;16287
RI: 871; 24514
PotD: 850; 13622
SC2003: 474; 15658
topic=10461711&message=108886833
GenMay
Penny Arcade
p=1064644
RottenTomatoes:
GenD: 1210606 71339
d=3051548
IGN: Total Messages: 61,436,445 (40,946 posted today)
Vestibule: 383,286 5,874,768 7:27pm
p
A bit of analysis (Score:1)
Forum Planet: 13029 (all time high)
Ebay: 22773
TechTV: 7012 (all time low; and my first data had negative...odd error on my part)
UltWedding: 3678 (I guess I drop this)
Main (Rotten Tomatoes): 3000 (over the past several days)
Go-Gaia has been reset to below where it started.
Must take less data (Score:1)
LUE: 2505; 36606 10/08 7:16PM
CE: 1731; 16554
RI: 933; 23699
PotD: 1110; 16778
SC2003: 682; 19372 10/08 7:18PM
topic=10477989&message=109068006
GenMay: 212,748 threads in total | 5,025,689 posts in total
General Mayhem: 4346466 175850
d=5100844
PennyArcade
p=1069106
RottenTomatoes:
Gen D: 1213237 71454
d=3058598
IGN: 61,487,431 (39,350 posted today)
Vest: 384,322 5,889,313 7:29pm
p=46398298
Slashdot
p=716822
Bad TechTVt data (Score:1)
Lesserdata (Score:1)
Rotten
GenD: 1216120 71587
Go-Gaia: Our forums have a total of 4938635 articles
Chatterbox: 14533 1036247
GenD: 9918 429233
p=7736981
Forum Planet: 1,059,561 Topics 11,457,554 Posts
tid=1185567&rid=12544968
EBay:
e=15674448
TechTV
d=1980107
UltWedding: Threads: 138,685, Posts: 3,643,042
d=5150616
And some results (Score:1)
Go-Gaia: 98887
EBay: Massive Pruge -- can't tell anything
ForumPlanet: 11750
TechTV: 6191 (yet another recrod low)
UltimateWedding: 4584 (record high)
General Discussion (Rotten Tomatoes): 5514 (wow, the past