The Matrix is control
In Reloaded we start to see a blurring between the matrix and the not-matrix. Here are the incidents I remember:
- Smith posesses human who then logs out to not-matrix. This copy seems mad, but still has Smith's best interests at heart.
- Smith's transendence causes Neo to suddenly start out of sleep in not-matrix.
- Neo can sense the oncoming squiddies,
- Neo stops the squiddies using his matrix gift (or perhaps he's just delusional and its cinematic coincidence that the rescue ships triggers its EMP right when he reaches out his hand.)
Is the not-matrix also a simulation, built for similar purposes to the matrix? I don't see enough evidence to judge either way right now, that's why I want your comments.
The biggest plot twist of this movie was the revelation that The One has already lived through the Matrix revolution five other times, like the dali-lama of ass-kicking. That would seem to suggest that it is at least 2600 A.D.
Here I don't understand the machine logic. Apperantly The Ones are born every now and again, and they can't be stopped in the Matrix. But why not? In the first film a lot of Neo's survival was due to the agents repeatedly underestimating him. I thought at first the REMFs in Matrix-HQ were misleading their agents, but by Reloaded Smith for-sure knows the Matrix is repeating. ("Everything is happening exactly as before." "Well not everything"). So the truth is out there, if programs have a head on their shoulders.
If The Architect(tm) is to be believed, the human slaves of the matrix must have the possibility of choice. Otherwise they will reject the programming and "crops will be lost". Given the choice to rebel, they counter-intuitively do not. At least "99%" do not. Choice is a safety valve to keep too much pressure out of the system, but periodically this leads to eruptions (The One/Zion).
However these eruptions are easily managed. Just stand The One up, and give him a choice. On the one hand genocide humans and kick the machines in the nuts. On the other, surrender, let Zion get slaughtered, and rise again like a phoenix from the ashes.
Its not clear which choice Neo takes. At the last second, The Architect (tm) changes the options to "salvation for Zion" versus "reenter the Matrix and accept that Trinity is going to die". How these map onto the previous two choices is unclear. Perhaps Trinity will be among the "seed" new rebels who are supposed to start the new Zion? I'm confused.
The lack of chaos in the The One cycle is astounding. It seems like in the shitty environment of Zion, one time in three he'd end up contracting some fatal disease, or step on a land mine, or something. And there are little variations, even within the matrix. His attachment to Trinity versus humanity. His faster response times to The Architect. Smith. Haven't these guys heard of the butterfly effect?
Just as a simple example, the "third ship" is destroyed by a robot bomb. The real reason it was destroyed was the guy going to press the EMP button had the misfortune to be walking on a loose catwalk that collapsed. If we're to believe that the not-matrix is not a simulation, then I believe there's no way for anyone to know in advance that that ship is going to explode. Thus there's no reason to know that their matrix mission will fail. Thus there's no reason for Trinity to enter the matrix. Thus there's no reason for Neo to choose the door on his left. Hm.
So I guess not-matrix has to be a simulation. Thoughts?