Forgot your password?

typodupeerror

Comment: Copyrights and older papers (Score 3, Insightful) 178

by sfkaplan (#39786545) Attached to: Harvard: Journals Too Expensive, Switch To Open Access

It would be a good thing for academia to move away from predatory publishers like Elsevier and Wiley, and conduct all future publication through open access journals. However, even if this wonderful thing happens, those publishers remain a problem. Let's say that Elsevier goes out of business when researchers stop publishing with them and libraries stop ordering their materials. The citation chain still goes through a large number of already existing Elsevier publications. If Elsevier disappears, our heavily limiting copyright laws leave no mechanism to obtain these older papers. Some libraries gave up on paper versions of journals in recent years, so even they have neither duplicates nor access to the papers.

Part of solving the academic publishing problem needs to include changes to copyright law. Authors should be permitted to provide access to papers that their publisher no longer makes available. Libraries should be allowed to provide access to academic publications whose copyright holders have vanished. There needs to be some mechanism along these lines, or else Elsevier and their ilk will gouge the academic libraries even more severely.

Comment: Re:What's wrong with Ron Paul? (Score 1) 577

by sfkaplan (#39646709) Attached to: Santorum Suspends Presidential Campaign

(e) ...Or force us to buy insurance we don't want.

At first, I accepted that the Affordable Care Act might be pushing the limits of the Commerce Clause. Then I came across the Militia Act of 1792, in which a bunch of Founding Fathers -- the ones who wrote the Commerce Clause -- compelled private citizens to purchase muskets and ammunition. From that precedent, any argument that the health insurance mandate exceeds the powers intended by the Framers goes poof.

Comment: Re:Why not? (Score 1) 689

by sfkaplan (#36764844) Attached to: Pastafarian Wins Right To Wear Colander In License Photo

You fail basic cost/benefit analytic thinking. It is not instructive to consider circumcisions and mastectomies as equivalent procedures. Consequently, mastectomies are performed only when a significant benefit is needed to outweigh the costs of such an invasive procedure. Circumcision is less invasive and has a low rate of complications; it is against those costs that each parent should weigh the benefits.

Comment: Re:Why not? (Score 1) 689

by sfkaplan (#36763582) Attached to: Pastafarian Wins Right To Wear Colander In License Photo
So reducing your odds of contracting STI's or penile cancer "antiquated, stupid fucking reasons"? How about medical conditions for uncircumcised penises (e.g., infections of the foreskin) that may require a circumcision later in life, thus requiring a more painful and protracted healing period? If circumcision were, as you assert, just a tradition or ritual, then yes, it would be a foolish and avoidable practice. However, the current research suggests a modest medical benefit from circumcision, even if you account for good hygiene and care. Like any medical procedure, it carries risks to be weighed against its benefits; that hardly, though, makes it "UN-NECESSARY".

Comment: Re:Libraries have become daytime homeless shelters (Score 1) 164

by sfkaplan (#35454806) Attached to: Should Public Libraries Become Hacker Spaces?

Wow, what a horrible generalization based on nothing. In spite of the wonderful spaces that libraries provide -- not only the raw tools for being engrossed in reading, writing, and thinking, but also the inspiring environment of being surrounded by other people doing those exact things -- you're willing to broadly diminish the role of libraries because some locations provide insufficient support for the homeless.

Methinks you need to allow a little more complexity in your evaluations. Libraries are such wonderful places for the curious and creative. To claim that you want your "maker spaces" (what a horrid choice of words) to be kept semi-private so that you don't need to be uncomfortable or inconvenienced is selfish. Solve the problem properly: Look for ways to support the homeless in your community (public or private, whichever you think best for the purpose); then leave the libraries public so that anyone who is creative or inquisitive has a good place to visit.

Comment: Re:people do banking online, why not voting? (Score 1) 304

by sfkaplan (#35272664) Attached to: WA Election To Try Online Voting

There is a single and profound difference between banking and voting: anonymity. It is a property that is at odds with just about every other property you might want for a communications system. Voting is particularly vexing because (1) you need to validate identity so that only enrolled voters can participate, but (2) you need to guarantee that no voter can be tied to their vote. If you think about how polling stations are designed, these two tasks are clearly and obviously performed, yet decoupled. How do you guarantee that the computer system on the other end of the network is going to validate your identity, but then forget it when recording your vote?

There is no part of banking or finance that involves anonymity. That's why ATMs and then online banking were relatively easy to design and deploy, and why online voting is so damned hard.

Comment: Re:Biggest legal issue, IMO (Score 5, Insightful) 741

by sfkaplan (#34288552) Attached to: Bruce Schneier vs. the TSA

The "think of the children" defense is perfectly applicable here. It is not just a superfluous use of children's issues to misdirect people from the real issue; here, patting-down children causes real harm, and draws people's attention to the primary issue itself. I agree that the groping of adults should be enough to stop this behavior on the part of the TSA, but the role that children play in this situation is different and compelling. As the GP pointed out, not only are these pat-downs useless when used on children, but they also monstrously undermine healthy efforts to teach children to protect their own bodies. The practice on adults is offensive and useless; on children it is perverse, reprehensible, and cruel.

Moreover, be practical: The hardest part of fixing this problem is getting the attention of beauracrats, which means getting the attention of the public and media for long enough for those beauracrats "care". Highlighting that children are being needlessly affected here, and that the TSA is removing children from their parents' control, are real problems that get the attention needed to fix the problem.

Comment: Re:I enjoy taking notes more (Score 0) 373

by sfkaplan (#32556348) Attached to: For taking notes by hand, I prefer ...

Moleskines are indeed nice, but I have found that the paper isn't as absorbent as I'd like it to be, which matters when using a fountain pen (my writing implement of choice). I also prefer a hardcover, since I'm not so easy on my notebooks.

Years ago, when cleaning out a great-uncle's house after he had died, my parents found a couple of blank National record books. After years of trying different notebook types, including Moleskine, these were exactly what I had always wanted. Good paper that is meant to last, hardcover protection, full-sized paper, pre-numbered pages, and just a good overall feel made them ideal for serious writing and note-taking. I could carry them along with books/laptop/papers, and they withstood the abuse over time. They're neither trendy nor cheap, but I strongly recommend giving them a try.

Comment: Re:Not again (Score 0) 686

by sfkaplan (#30487296) Attached to: Not Enough Women In Computing, Or Too Many Men?

Such a convenient and unjustified answer: "Oh, there are so few women because they don't *want* to do computing! It's just that simple!"

How about some data: Science and engineering degrees granted to women

Female bachelor's degrees in CS peaked in the mid 1980's, and have steadily declined since. Almost every other field has been increasing the number of women who obtain science and engineering degrees, with the notable exception of math (holding steady) and computer science (steadily decreasing).

Nobody claims here that the split *should* be 50% of each gender. However, this data is evidence that the current split of 1:3 or 1:4 isn't natural either, unless you want to claim that women have fundamentally become *less* interesting in computing over the last 25 years. It isn't good enough to state, without justification, "Meh, girls just don't like computing." Not so long ago, more of them did.

Comment: Re:dm-crypt (Score 0) 312

by sfkaplan (#30268960) Attached to: Network Security While Traveling?
That's a nice ideal, but it's impractical. What is my wife supposed to do if I get hit by a bus? She would need access to some of those accounts, and she can't possibly be expected to remember my passwords without any written aids. Storing them in some encrypted form that she can access preserves that information in a safe manner, and it allows me to use better, more diverse passwords.
Privacy

Ontario Court Wrong About IP Addresses, Too 258

Posted by kdawson
from the reasoning-by-bad-analogy dept.
Frequent Slashdot contributor Bennett Haselton comments on a breaking news story out of the Canadian courts: "An Ontario Superior Court Justice has ruled that Canadian police can obtain the identities of Internet users without a warrant, writing that there is 'no reasonable expectation of privacy' for a user's online identity, and drawing the analogy that 'One's name and address or the name and address of your spouse are not biographical information one expects would be kept private from the state.' But why in the world is it valid to compare an IP address with a street address in the phone book?" Read on for Bennett's analysis.
Image

Slashdot's Disagree Mail 135

Posted by samzenpus
from the they-keep-coming dept.
This installment of Disagree Mail highlights a man's concern about illegal cloning in the Hollywood community, a guy who is sick of US imperialism and his low karma, and an example of the kind of people you don't want as roommates in college. Read below to find out just how crazy, angry and irresponsible it gets.
Communications

The State of UK Broadband — Not So Fast 279

Posted by kdawson
from the but-you-have-actual-competition dept.
Barence writes "The deplorable speed of British broadband connections has been revealed in the latest figures from the Office of National Statistics, which show that 42.3% of broadband connections are slower than 2Mb/sec. More worryingly, the ONS statistics are based on the connection's headline speed, not actual throughput, which means that many more British broadband connections are effectively below the 2Mb/sec barrier. Better still, a separate report issued yesterday by Ofcom revealed that the majority of broadband users had no idea about the speed of their connection anyway."
Music

At Atlantic Records, Digital Sales Surpass CDs 273

Posted by kdawson
from the trading-analog-dollars-for-digital-pennies dept.
The NYTimes reports that Atlantic is the first major label to report getting a majority of its revenue from digital sales, not CDs. Analysts say that Atlantic is out in front — the industry as a whole isn't expected to hit the 50% mark until 2011. By 2013, music industry revenues will be 37% down from their 1999 levels (when Napster arrived on the scene), according to Forrester. "'It's not at all clear that digital economics can make up for the drop in physical,' said John Rose, a former executive at EMI ... Instead, the music industry is now hoping to find growth from a variety of other revenue streams it has not always had access to, like concert ticket sales and merchandise from artist tours. ... In virtually all... corners of the media world, executives are fighting to hold onto as much of their old business as possible while transitioning to digital — a difficult process that NBC Universal's chief executive ... has described as 'trading analog dollars for digital pennies.'"

Comment: Re:Perceived delay (Score 0) 391

by sfkaplan (#21642395) Attached to: Linux To Take Over The Low-End PC Market?

> Yes I needed. This is the misconfiguration that makes it take a full 3 minutes to load. Otherwise it will load in 20-30 seconds in a 128MB system. Not if 90% of system and app libraries are stuck in swap.

If that is the case, then the mistake is not in the configuration but rather in the Linux kernel's virtual memory management. The portion of the libraries needed for efficient execution should be kept in RAM by a good vritual memory system, making the use of swap space irrelevant. In fact, the size of the swap doesn't matter here at all -- whether it was 256 MB or 1 TB, the virtual memory system will not elect to evict more pages just because there is more swap available.

Idaho state law makes it illegal for a man to give his sweetheart a box of candy weighing less than fifty pounds.

Working...