I've been reading Slashdot since the early days (ugh, wish I would have registered and gotten a lower user id
I'm not saying I succeed at the higher levels of quality consistently, but I'm polite and I try to add value to the discussions. Contrary to historical norms, I've been fairly astounded by the number of "troll", "flamebait" and other negative moderations on my posts lately. If anything, over the years I've mellowed and become more polite in my communications; but the negative moderations are pretty glaringly obvious in my admittedly-anecdotal case.
I tend to be skeptical compared to the norm, and my posts often express a contrarian point of view. In the not-too-distant past, that contrarian point of view would have merited a decent amount of "insightful" moderations. These days, however, many posts that are simply questioning or opposing the traditional Slashdot groupthink are moderated troll or flamebait. What the hell?
If I had to guess, I'd say that the removal of metamoderation from the moderating system has given moderators an unhealthy amount of freedom in being negative in moderation. It's brought out the worst in moderators. It's like chickens in the henhouse pecking the odd bird to death. If you don't toe the line, moderation will eliminate you from the discussion. Instead of having healthy debate on topics where thought provoking comments from all sides bubble up to the top of the moderated pile, you end up with a homogeneity of opinion that frankly gets a bit boring.
Yes, the RIAA is the anti-christ. They have no reason to fear piracy ever. Copyright in all forms should be abolished because it's the right thing to do, not because file downloaders don't want to pay the price being asked for by the content creators. The science and models proving that Global Warming is man made and going to wipe out all the coastal cities in the next 50 years is unassailable and should never be questioned. The CRU wasn't guilty of dodgy anti-peer, anti-Science behavior, and even questioning it or suggesting they keep to a higher standard means that you're a troll. Microsoft is evil, Apple has become evil, Google is evil... hell, all corporations are evil, management is evil, capitalism is evil... on and on and on.
Besides just wanting to vent, I'm interested in fielding opinions from others on