Slashdot stories can be listened to in audio form via an RSS feed, as read by our own robotic overlord.

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Slashdot videos: Now with more Slashdot!

  • View

  • Discuss

  • Share

We've improved Slashdot's video section; now you can view our video interviews, product close-ups and site visits with all the usual Slashdot options to comment, share, etc. No more walled garden! It's a work in progress -- we hope you'll check it out (Learn more about the recent updates).

×

Comment: Re:"Support" != actually sacrifice for (Score 2) 458

by hsthompson69 (#48943817) Attached to: Most Americans Support Government Action On Climate Change

There you go again, pointing out truths that environmentalists don't want to hear :)

Don't worry, after they finally admit that CO2 doesn't drive global average temperatures or climactic swings, they'll find some *other* component of energy generation (say, magnetic fields, or plain old waste heat), and they'll demonize the hell out of that because it's causing a spotted tit-fox, or marsh trout to die off.

Warming, cooling, staying the same - none of it matters when it comes to "the consensus" :)

Comment: Re:Therefore justifying the killing of others (Score 1) 894

by hsthompson69 (#48836019) Attached to: Pope Francis: There Are Limits To Freedom of Expression

Wasn't trying to push a button at all - I've got no problem with your cowardice, and obviously neither do you.

The only problem I have is your seeming insistence that others should share your cowardice. I get your point - I understand your argument about being cautious when dealing with over-sensitive and violent and/or powerful people.

Do you understand that others might value their principles over the caution you recommend? Or is that simply incomprehensible to you?

Comment: Re:Therefore justifying the killing of others (Score 1) 894

by hsthompson69 (#48831997) Attached to: Pope Francis: There Are Limits To Freedom of Expression

So, you're a coward who frankly doesn't care about what other people think about their cowardice - a perfectly rational point of view, and I congratulate you for it :)

That being said...

1) it's not just about depicting mohammad, it's about mocking him, and other core beliefs of islam;

2) german anti-free speech laws are part of their culture;

3) fair enough - there are arguments for liberalization, as well as criminalization.

Can you understand why other people might not share your cowardice? It seems that your underlying assertion is "I'm a coward, and anyone else who isn't is completely irrational and stupid"...which, of course, is your free speech right to say, in my book :)

Comment: Re:Therefore justifying the killing of others (Score 1) 894

by hsthompson69 (#48831269) Attached to: Pope Francis: There Are Limits To Freedom of Expression

Because expressing free speech is the moral equivalent of buying crack, right? :)

Your point of view is clear - you don't believe that either islamic culture, german culture, or drug laws should be changed.

Sounds like you're ready to say, "sure, go ahead, sit in the front of the segregated bus, while you're at it".

But hey, that's okay - if you want to be a coward, and just let the threats of the status quo determine the ability for people to exercise their freedoms, that's a perfectly reasonable position to take to minimize risk. Just don't expect people to be all that impressed with your point of view :)

Comment: Re:And now that hard drives have gotten cheaper... (Score 1) 441

by hsthompson69 (#48830217) Attached to: Why We Have To Kiss Off Big Carbon Now

Ah, the "externalities" trope.

Your imagined, unrealized externalities of the future may indeed be dire, but that has nothing to do with whether cheap energy is a good thing.

Let's, for a moment, imagine a dire, future externality of solar power - say the ivanpah generator, reflecting into space, attracts a violent alien civilization that comes and eats 90% of our population. Are you happy to pad the pockets of solar executives at the expense of the future?

Now, maybe if you had concrete, actual, real "externalities" that were paid by "all of us", like say, solar subsidies for bird zapping solar plants in nevada, or regulations that raised the cost of energy paid by "all of us", you'd have a case to make...but imaginary harms in some hypothetical future with tenuous attribution hardly make for good economics.

Comment: Re:Therefore justifying the killing of others (Score 1) 894

by hsthompson69 (#48830147) Attached to: Pope Francis: There Are Limits To Freedom of Expression

Got it, the "don't do risky stuff because people are crazy" line of thinking...

like don't wear a short skirt in a bad neighborhood if you don't want to be raped...

or don't be a black person whistling at a white woman if you don't want to be lynched...

or don't let people know you're gay if you don't want to be subject to chemical castration even if you happened to have saved millions of people during WWII with your code breaking work.

If I'm being to subtle, let me state it plainly - the problem isn't people who make fun of the holocaust or muhammad, it's the people who react against such speech in violent or oppressive ways. While we can raise our hands and just say, "well, that's just the way it is", if one truly believes in free speech, one must take up the fight against such backwards cultures, and not be intimidated by their threats that it will "not turn out well and stuff".

Comment: Re:Therefore justifying the killing of others (Score 1) 894

by hsthompson69 (#48827369) Attached to: Pope Francis: There Are Limits To Freedom of Expression

Well, what you said was:

"Do you think drawing cartoons of Muhammad and making fun of him is "something that almost certainly needs to be said?"

"Shouldn't you go, right now, and draw funny cartoons that deny the Holocaust?"

My answer to both, is yes.

Whether or not you actually were trying to make a point with your questions, I suppose is an open question :)

Did you have a point?

Comment: And now that hard drives have gotten cheaper... (Score 1) 441

by hsthompson69 (#48826159) Attached to: Why We Have To Kiss Off Big Carbon Now

...damn, we all better stop using computers!

Seriously, though, cheap energy (in absolute terms, not massaged by the heavy hand of regulation), is a good thing. Great, so we don't invest in more oil drilling...until consumption goes up, prices go up, and it becomes profitable. This is a *feature* not a bug.

Prices are momentary signals, not eternal mandates.

Comment: Re:Therefore justifying the killing of others (Score 1) 894

by hsthompson69 (#48826135) Attached to: Pope Francis: There Are Limits To Freedom of Expression

And your point is that Germany sucks for being oppressive of free speech, or that Germany rocks for being oppressive of free speech?

Or, are you saying that Germany sucks for being oppressive of free speech, and then suddenly being all pro-free speech when it comes to Charlie Hebdo? If that's the case, then I agree - the world is filled with leftist hypocrites who imagine "freedom of speech" as only for the ideas they hold dear.

I believe significantly differently.

Comment: Re:Pope Francis - fuck your mother (Score 1) 894

by hsthompson69 (#48821457) Attached to: Pope Francis: There Are Limits To Freedom of Expression

The whole "fighting words" thing seems like an excuse to infantilize adults. If someone literally says something like, "I'm going to take my gun out and shoot you in the head right now", maybe you've got a right to respond to that threat...but just insulting something sacred to them?

Fuck that.

No directory.

Working...