Comment: Re:Environmental Wackos (Score 4, Insightful) 2008-07-21 15:03
by
Red Flayer
on Monday July 21, @03:03PM
(#24275093)
Attached to: China Races To Clean Up Olympic Air
Attached to: China Races To Clean Up Olympic Air
I agree with you in general regarding China's pollution problem, but the racist overtones (Egg Foo Young?) are unnecessary.
That said, maybe if you look back at the industrial revolution in "cleaner" countries, we were just as bad. Read accounts of Liverpool in the 18th, 19th and early 20th century. Or how about chemical pollution in the US until the 1970s?
China's position on pollution is no different than what other countries went through... the difference is just one of scale.
This does not mean that China's attitude towards pollution is any more tenable, but it helps if we consider the processes by which other countries cleaned up their acts. Of note, grassroots support for a cleaner environment is problematic in China, given their political system, and the ease by which laws can be overlooked.
But it doesn't reflect well on Americans (or other Westerners) to chastise China while ignoring our own sordid past.
That said, maybe if you look back at the industrial revolution in "cleaner" countries, we were just as bad. Read accounts of Liverpool in the 18th, 19th and early 20th century. Or how about chemical pollution in the US until the 1970s?
China's position on pollution is no different than what other countries went through... the difference is just one of scale.
This does not mean that China's attitude towards pollution is any more tenable, but it helps if we consider the processes by which other countries cleaned up their acts. Of note, grassroots support for a cleaner environment is problematic in China, given their political system, and the ease by which laws can be overlooked.
But it doesn't reflect well on Americans (or other Westerners) to chastise China while ignoring our own sordid past.

