Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment: Re:Irrelevant (Score 2) 74

Yes, marketing is worse than government surveillance...

So a service provider gathering data on the way its customers use the service for marketing purposes (which the customer agreed to by contract) is worse than the government secretly surveilling its own citizens?

Nice!

Comment: Re:What about my rights? (Score 1) 172

by SpankiMonki (#47587073) Attached to: US States Edge Toward Cryptocoin Regulation
Look, if you've honestly put in the effort to research the issues and are satisfied with your conclusion that FRB is possible with bitcoin, than I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. But as I stated earlier, I'm not interested in taking the time to spell out my position. Additionally, I'm certainly not interested in digging up the various threads/posts/papers I've read over the past years in order to spoon-feed them to "some guy on the internet". I pointed you in a direction where you might come across some good arguments challenging your position; if you went down that road and remain unconvinced, then so be it.

It...but certainly Mt. Gox could have done it well before its collapse. People were using it as a bank.

Lemme get this straight, you're claiming that:

  • 1) because people had BTC on account with MtGox in order to facilitate trades, they were actually using MtGox as a bank
    2) MtGox could have started writing loans using its customer's BTC balances

...have I got that right?

OK, then. I think I now have a much better idea of where you're coming from.

Cheers!

Comment: Re:What about my rights? (Score 1) 172

by SpankiMonki (#47581413) Attached to: US States Edge Toward Cryptocoin Regulation

No, I used the on-site search, and missed that page. It says that FRB with Bitcoin is possible, which contradicts what you are saying.

Apparently you didn't bother to click through the links on that page (or read any of the threads on the forum) that express opposing viewpoints. Now, I don't really follow bitcoin that closely anymore, but the last I checked the matter was hardly settled.

But hey, if you can point to a real world example of an operational bitcoin bank practicing fractional reserve banking, I'd certainly be willing to reconsider my position. : )

Back to my example

Please, spare me. I can assure you that my professional credentials in the banking arena are...well, let's say they're above average.

They also used to have a role in safeguarding money, much less important with Bitcoin.

Off-topic, but you can't be serious. The total amount of stolen bitcoins compared to the total amount in circulation is staggering.

Comment: Re:If true. If. (Score 2) 200

Derp. Welcome to America. As it's been this way since the days of Andrew Jackson.

How dare you try to lay our sorry state of affairs at the feet of President Jackson! Don't you realize what a fucked up country he inherited from John Quincy Adams?!? You've obviously been spending WAY to much time in your RWEC. (Right-Whig Echo Chamber)

Comment: Re:What about my rights? (Score 1) 172

by SpankiMonki (#47569381) Attached to: US States Edge Toward Cryptocoin Regulation

This is fractional reserve banking. It works with any currency, as long as there's a way to lend it out.

Sorry, with bitcoin I'm afraid it's not that simple. At this point in the discussion, I'm not going to bother with writing out a treatise explaining my position. If you really want to understand the issues involved, I suggest you check the bitcoin wiki along with the many threads on the topic at bitcointalk.org.

Comment: Re:What about my rights? (Score 1) 172

by SpankiMonki (#47562037) Attached to: US States Edge Toward Cryptocoin Regulation

Lending of those assets? Check.

[sigh]

Again, you seem to have a different definition than everyone else of what constitutes "lending". If individuals at MtGox were appropriating customer deposits, that's not a lending activity, that's a criminal activity. And it's still criminal even if they returned the BTC with interest.

Furthermore, at no time did MtGox sell or offer for sale any BTC loan products. If you're not making loans, you're not a bank by any generally accepted definition.

Sure sounds like it meets at least one public definition of fractional reserve banking.

...only if one subscribes to your ridiculous position that appropriating customer deposits is equivalent to lending. But please, continue making up new definitions for common words...it's quite entertaining. I'm sure you're a real hit at cocktail parties.

Cheers!

Comment: Re:What about my rights? (Score 1) 172

by SpankiMonki (#47560369) Attached to: US States Edge Toward Cryptocoin Regulation

The original request said the system did not allow fractional reserve [banking], and you cannot believe that in light of the evidence that fractional reserve did exist.

You're right, I don't believe fractional reserve banking with bitcoin can exist, and you have yet to provide any evidence to the contrary.

MtGox was operating with a fractional reserve for some time. Either intentionally (criminal) or not (negligent).

So...in your mind, BTC exchanges are operating as fractional reserve banks. That's a rather...um, unique position to hold. I suspect the operators and customers of the exchanges would disagree with you, though.

There is at least one bitcoin "bank" currently offering to pay interest on bitcoin deposits.

Just because businesses are paying interest on bitcoin deposits and/or charging interest on BTC loans does not mean they qualify as fractional reserve banks. But since your definition of fractional reserve banking seems to differ from the generally accepted definition, I guess you can make any claim you want. In any case, it sure would help your argument(s) if you could back them up somehow.

Comment: Re:What about my rights? (Score 1) 172

by SpankiMonki (#47553767) Attached to: US States Edge Toward Cryptocoin Regulation

Read the rules closely and you can figure out it bans opening a BitCoin bank in NY. Basically, if you take deposits it needs to 100% back by BitCoins, so no fractional reserve banking.

You can't use bitcoin for fractional reserve banking; the system itself doesn't support it. Legislation banning fractional reserve banking in BTC is like legislation banning the sun from rising in the west.

The degree of technical confidence is inversely proportional to the level of management.

Working...