Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

News for nerds, stuff that matters

Slashdot Log In

Log In

[ Create a new account ]

RailGunner (554645)

RailGunner
  (email not shown publicly)
http://www.railgunnerforpresident.com/

Journal of RailGunner (554645)

Medusa's Coil, by H.P. Lovecraft

[ #197176 ]
Wednesday February 27, @01:23PM
User Journal
Warning: Spoilers

Review: Hated it.

Well, actually, I enjoyed it at the beginning and middle of the story, and found the story fairly riveting when it looked like Marceline was simply a Gorgon or perhaps a type of Succubus. And the descriptions of her hair were very well written. And when she "comes back" - that was pretty creepy.

But the ending just killed the whole story. For Lovecraft, the horror was not so much that Marceline was an undead gorgon, but that she was of African descent. Wow, Mr. Lovecraft, way to flush my enjoyment of that story right down the toilet.

This is almost as bad as the brutally racist description of the boxer in "Herbert West: Re-Animator" where he tries to invoke fear by mentioning the "drums of the Congo".

You know, I like the Macabre style of his writings, and the atmosphere, but honestly, Lovecraft's overt, blatant, and ridiculous racism really wrecks it for me.

Despite not having read other "classics" like the "Call of Cthulhu" yet, I think I'm selling this book to a reseller this weekend.

Lovecraft was a racist.

Off topic: Mark Twain wasn't. Get past the N-Word and Huckleberry Finn is a story about how stupid racism is.

I guess I'll ask the 'dot: Is there an author who is similar to Lovecraft in style that I should check out? Don't say Poe, I've already read the entirety of Poe's works.
This discussion was created by RailGunner (554645) as no Foes, but now has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
 Full
 Abbreviated
 Hidden
More | Login
Loading... please wait.
  • While there may seem to be quite a degree of overt racism in some of his writings, I'm not quite sure if Lovecraft really was a racist, as you say. His descriptions of Robinson as a "loathesome African monstrosity" is countered in the end by the fact that reanimation does work on a person some thought at the time to be sub- or non-human. You may also want to read "Facts Concerning the Late Arthur Jermyn and His Family" before you make up your mind.
    • You may also want to read "Facts Concerning the Late Arthur Jermyn and His Family" before you make up your mind.

      Thanks, I will do so. I'm relatively new to Lovecraft, and while I enjoyed "The Cats of Ulthar" , "The Terrible Old Man", "The Music of Erich Zann" and I really liked "Cool Air" - even if I figured it out right away, Medusa's Coil really left a bad taste with the ending - especially after reading "Herbert West: Re-Animator".

  • The only decent person in the whole thing is Jim. The N-bombs are appropriate because he was capturing the Southern dialect from that era. I cannot tell you how much it irks me that people want to ban it because of the N-bombs when it is such a powerful statement against racism and slavery.

    As for Lovecraft... I am also a fairly new reader of Lovecraft and, to be honest, he bored me. I got a collection of his stories and they were all almost the exact same thing. Old house. Twisted in darkness. Tied

  • I just put up a journal about a social networking reading site called Goodreads [goodreads.com]. They have groups that are dedicated to helping you find authors you may like based on past authors, genre, and all. I have no really good suggestions for you, but some of the groups there might. (If you sign up there and are interested, hit up my email address (insanecarbonbasedlifeform at the google mail service), and I'll pass on my user name on there to you).
  • If you're hankering for some Lovecraft, you could do worse than pick up a few of Mignola's Hellboy collections. Plus, what with you having a young'un, at least when he's exposed to comic books, he'll be exposed to good ones.