I'm a Tolkien fanboy, and I was pleasantly surprised at PJ's LOTR films.
There were some very odd decisions, but all in all the LOTR movies were surprisingly good.
The Hobbit films are really forgettable, except for a few great scenes here and there, which are about %20 of the total.
Where? I am hard pressed to think of something for the 1st movie and I haven't seen a single good scene anywhere in the 2nd Hobbit movie. Maybe I missed something?