say my wireless router is open for anyone and i have a tor bridge running at any time ... on top of that every time i connect from my own pc i go through a vpn ... how would that translate then?
the car analogies do seem to work for everything but it is in fact completely not the same. First of all, even if you would agree to call it stealing the car you steal from an individual who's life gets seriously and directly affected to the point of possible ruin whereas uploading/downloading a cd does not directly have the impact on one single person/family possibly losing their cosy life over one single fact. I think that's what the metaphor means in fact so maybe everyone would want to de-bunch the panties here.
Other than that i'm not getting into it. Anyone seeing soapy-pipey or act-e as reasonably and in any way defendable probably hasn't read anything about the options it opens up. People who can't afford will still want it. Wherever there's a niche, business is created. It's the universal law of vacuum needs to be filled, a bit like with the quantum foam theory. The thing is here they are attacking the peoples who share this sh-t for free, not even making any money off of it because they are easy to extort because they are just Joe average, downloadmom and uploadson who worked their assess for what little they have and are scared to lose it so they easily budge under legal threat, viable or not.
I have to see i think they are achieving quite the opposite of the desired effect with their reign of terror. The resilience has become more or less vibrant. It used to be some underground thing until they started advertising, now everyone knows about it, and knows how to do it.
so in fact, i would agree that it is all more or less : BS :p