Comment: Re:There's Your Problem Right There (Score 1) 1108
Speciation is kind of a tricky idea to pin down. I took some supplemental biology classes a few years back and finally had it explained to me in a sensible way. I'd always heard species defined as those animals that, when bred, could not produce sterile offspring. It always troubled me, though, WHEN does that happen? When one mutation finally pushes an animal over that threshold and it can't breed with the rest of the animals, how would that line continue to develop?
What I learned is that speciation happens by degrees, beginning, typically with populations of animals that can't breed together they are separated. As the animals evolve different structures or behaviours, they WON'T breed together if introduced, even if genetically compatible. And then finally, after many generations, the two populations become so genetically distinct that their mating couldn't produce fertile offspring. Dogs and wolves are probably still the same species and could/would mate if allowed to - but some dog breeds may be too small or have behaviours too different from wild wolves for them to mate. In-vitro fertilization would probably produce fertile offspring even in those cases. Who knows how long it will take for them to genetically diverge altogether.