This dumbest thing me see on slashdot in long time. Air free everywhere people live. Nobody have to give it to you. To deprive someone of air, you need to move them out of normal habitat. That violate rights. Me think you being deliberately obtuse.
And why you ask "Are you saying that I wouldn't be depriving you of your rights if I took away your right to breathe?"
Of course he no say that. If you take away Y's right to X, then you deprive Y of a right. That line always true. That line tautology. You not know logic, or you just not know how to write? Me feel your pain if the latter.