Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Randomness and information (Score 1) 165

True random data has maximal information content (or close to that at least).  Meaningful software does not.  It may be incomprehesible, but it is not random in nature, and there will always be many points of view from which it is far from random.  Find one of these, and you have a toehold into how it works.

Comment Evolution (Score 1) 1010

Both the biological theories of evolution and the alternative ideas you hear flying around are massively oversimplified compared to how reality is.  The basic principles of evolution are a mathematical consequence in many systems with feedback, for example dynamical systems.  The idea that evolution happens should be a no-brainer to most rational people.  The idea that our current understanding of the behaviour of systems that evolve over a long period of time is sufficient to explain our distant origins in any sufficiently detailed degree so as to be of practice use, however, is not so clear cut.  The idea that the fine detail sufficient to make accurate experimental predictions in real world cases is beyond what we can comprehend is a natural idea given modern notions of information and complexity, but have more in common with the 'ineffability of God' type ideas you find in religious circles, rather than either the 'we can know, we shall know' sentiment once uttered by Hilbert before Godel threw a spanner into the works of his plan to make the foundations of mathematics provably rigorous, and also the 'we have this pretty theory and we like it, therefore we _do_ know' type attitudes that are become all too common amongst sciency types these days.

I believe in evolution, but I don't believe current science properly understands evolution, nor will they for some time, so I seriously doubt anything beyond 'evolution has been going on for a long time and contributes massively to how we are today'.

Comment Religion is... (Score 1, Insightful) 392

Religion is, and has always been, the main way humans self-organise and coordinate on a large scale.  Modern civilisation has its advantages, but one drawback is that the rules are too numerous, can only really be understood by experts and is open to abuse by vested interests.  Religion also has these shortcomings, but is generally much simpler in nature.  We have a few thousand years of religious history to study how that part of human psychology works, and it is not surprising to see religious behaviour emerging naturally in secular aspects of life.  (Fans following a football team are probably an excellent source of examples here.)

Comment It is a good example of abuse (Score 1) 230

The copyright system was originally intended to provide a good balance between the rights of the public and those of the producer.  The producers are the ones who make the money, and they've use this to lobby for the balance to shift in their favour.  This is what happens when lobbying and campaign contributions are allowed in a democratic system: fairness goes out the window.

Comment Music and its benefits (Score 0) 328

As we move more and more to a greed and market driven life, this sort of thing will happen.  Music is of massive benefit to us all, especially the learning of an instrument and playing it with/to others.  Finding a way to make music pay is necessary, but as we have seen in many other markets, when the highest quality of carefully hand-produced things is not required, often there is a computer/technology based solution that, whilst poorer in quality, suffices for what's needed.

When composing for adverts, for example, sample libraries with phrases recorded by live players are useful.  Actually making a sampler-orchestra sound like a real one, however, is rather difficult.  You can mask the differences with non-orchestral sounds (which also leads the listeners ear to regard the whole thing as studio produced, so not to reject the sound as cheap and artificial).

But let us not forget that the value of music can't be measured in dollars or pounds.

Comment Re:If they are SO REALLY CONCERN about religion .. (Score 1) 674

In a level playing field, you'd be able to have faith and non-faith schools both with support and see which is the better.  Groups like the BHA seem to be campaigning for schools to be exclusively non-faith, based only on idealism without paying any attention to whether or not faith plays a functional role in learning and living (regardless of objective truth, which may seem like heresy to some, but it is an angle that needs serious consideration, since many things in everyday life and modern science are known to work, and work well, but for reasons that nobody understands).

There is a dire need to understand how faith functions in a persons life.

Comment Re:If they are SO REALLY CONCERN about religion .. (Score 1) 674

You can't argue with people who don't think things through or listen to reason.  Christian fundies are one such class of people, aggressive atheists like Dawkins are another.  When slanging matches start, it's a little like watching Jeremy Kyle or Jerry Springer...

Comment Re:She was a computer prophet (Score 1) 157

Though she missed the issue of reliability.  There's a reason certain mission critical setups don't run simple micros.  And supercomputers that use Xeon and suchlike are more than just micros in how they link things together.  But apart from those situations, yes, she was right: now micros dominate.

Slashdot Top Deals

Software production is assumed to be a line function, but it is run like a staff function. -- Paul Licker

Working...