Submission + - Seattle Blogger Successfully Defends Libel Suit (richardsilverstein.com)
richards1052 writes: "Los Angeles Superior Court Judge John Reid yesterday dismissed a suit filed by a controversial local pro-Israel activist who sued me for saying in my blog that she was a "Kahanist." She claimed that in doing so I had called her a terrorist, since there was an Israeli political party, Kahane Chai, which the U.S. Treasury Department labelled a terrorist organization.
The plaintiff, Rachel Neuwirth, also included noted Stanford University Middle East historian Joel Beinin as a party to her suit.
My pro bono attorneys filed an anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) arguing that a blog is a public forum, that the pro-Israel activist was a public figure, and the issues under discussion were vital ones that merited discussion in public discourse. The judge accepted our thinking and dismissed the suit.
This is a victory not only for blogging free speech, but for the widest possible discussion of the thorny issues surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. There are those who only believe in speech they agree with, while speech they disagree with should be stifled. This is a pernicious principle and one the court rejected.
The plaintiff will have to pay reasonable legal fees for the defendants."