Comment Re:Social Security For The Complete Idiot (Score 1) 436
Invested in the US government? Really? I guess you are making a semantic argument, but then people in the press wouldn't refer to SS going into "red"... meaning that it is paying out more than it is taking in.
http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2010/aug/5/social-security-red-first-time-ever/
In the commonly used definition of an investment, the institution does not/can not go into the red and remain viable. If it does, then that means it has failed, and everybody loses their money.
Your definition of investment seems more in line with Bernie Madoff's.