Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:What's the evidence this will work? (Score 1) 156

Did they compare test scores between kids using only the software, and kids using nothing at all (no teachers / classrooms)? Or did they test how well kids from illiterate families did in their first few years in school, comparing those having used educational software against those without? Because that's what we're talking about here.

Besides, one of the tested products apparently did have a significant impact on test scores, showing that computers can be effective as a supplement to regular education as well. I agree that there's a lot of rubbish educational software out there, but not all of it is.

Comment Re:Hey well... (Score 1) 132

Most tests (from manufacturers as well as consumer advocate groups) seem to indicate 10 years of service or about 3000 runs on average, with a few top brands consistently scoring 1.5 - 2x as good (5000 runs). This is for front loaders, mind; perhaps the numbers are different for top loaders (top loaders are virtually nonexistent here).

Comment Re:Hey well... (Score 2) 132

Every brand will have their good and bad models. My first combi oven was a Whirlpool and I was rather pleased with it: quiet, reliable and extremely intuitive to use. So when I moved house I got the latest model Whirlpool oven... and found it to be poorly built with an insane user interface.

The one brand I'd recommend (for dishwashers and washing machines) without hesitation is Miele. Expensive but built like a rock, they ought to last you a good 15-20 years (my parents replaced one after 28 years, during 15 of which it had run a load a day).

Comment Re:Heated Competition (Score 1) 132

In Russia I can believe it, but things there aren't always what they seem. I remember seeing a picture of a shopkeeper lady surrounded by guys in body armor, ski masks and carrying automatic weapons. Looked like a serious robbery, but the caption below read: "tax inspectors check the books in a shop on famous Arbat street.

Comment Re:Bureaucratic red tape (Score 4, Interesting) 119

A lot of cases where drones are being used commercially (aerial photography / site surveys / inspection of industrial installations) can still be done within the line-of-sight restriction. Because the operator still enjoys the other major aspects of drones: stable flight characteristics, and a telemetry+video downlink. I'm not a ig fan of regulations, but in this case I understand why they take a conservative stance for now.

Comment Re:What's the evidence this will work? (Score 1) 156

There is plenty of evidence that computer programs can effectively teach basic math and language skills, and that they are good for rote learning of various subjects. Are they better than a teacher or parent? They are better than no teacher or parent. And in addition to special teaching programs (which have limited application), computers can bring traditional learning materials to student at a much lower cost. If there is a shortage of teachers or if there aren't any in some remote area, kids can be taught in a MOOC or virtual classroom. Not as effective as small local classes, but better than none at all.

The question is not whether computers can improve education in underdeveloped countries; they can. The real question is how to apply computers in this (varied) environment so that they actually are effective... or whether it would be more cost-effective to spend the money on teachers.

Comment Re:Education....by computer (Score 1) 156

Computers did not teach you anyything, because you had a school with teachers and good learning materials (and probably well educated parents too) to learn from. Kids in underdeveloped countries often lack some of these, but they do (or will soon have) access to connected smart phones as that kind of tech is making its way into those markets. This will give kids access to teachers and books at the very least, and software can provide additional education. Software aimed at basic math and language is shown to be plenty effective.

Comment Re: Propheteering (Score 1) 131

"accomplishments"??? He was at the right time at the right place

Most of us have good ideas from time to time, and frequently at a time when conditions are favourable. What matters is what you do with that opportunity. First you have to recognize that the time and market are right for your idea, or you have to be willing to take a gamble on that. Next you need to organize capital and people to make it happen. That is where the accomplishment is.

Comment Re: Propheteering (Score 1) 131

Trickle-down works in economics as well, just not the way the likes of Bush promoted it. What is good for the super-rich is not necessarily good for the rest of us (usually it isn't), but a strong middle class has a positive impact on the lower class. Middle class wealth most certainly trickles down.

Comment Re:Yes we should but... (Score 2) 291

Coding is actually a good way to teach some of those skills. Especially a skill not mentioned in that list: troubleshooting. The good troubleshooters and problem solvers in my professional circle, whether they are managers, business analysts, project managers, consultants, or IT support staff, are almost always people who have done a bit of coding at some point in their life. Coding appears to be a great way to impart those skills even on people who will not be coding professionally, ever.

The real question is: can we fit a meaningful coding class into the high school curriculum? The coding classes I've seen so far have been given as part of math class, or consisted of a lame 3rd year high school course that lasted all of one semester. I'd say a real coding class is an hour or two a week over at least one year, preferably two. And why not? Hell, I was forced to take German and French for 2 years before I was allowed to drop it, so why not coding? (By the way: language class is useful as are coding classes, but for different reasons. I did get some benefit from them).

Comment Re:so... (Score 1) 271

The point of brand advertising is not to make you go out and buy a beer, but to make sure that when you do, you'll choose Budweiser. There is plenty of research that shows such advertising works. A while back, some marketroid told me about a female hygiene product that offered the same quality as the competition but cost 1,5 times as much, yet it was one of the more popular brands. The "secret" was that almost all of that extra margin was spent on brand advertising.

What is less clear is which brand ads work best. Facebook claims that their environment is better than Google's due to the "experience" factor, but I doubt that: the more you integrate the ad with the actual experience, the more pissed off your customers are going to be. Just look at TV ads, which they claim are similar to theirs.

Slashdot Top Deals

"Experience has proved that some people indeed know everything." -- Russell Baker

Working...