Comment Re:Smart move (oh god, I'm replying to AC) (Score 2, Informative) 1064
That's absolutely correct, there are many reasons for performing a "pap smear" on patient's without a cervix, the most cogent is a history of dysplasia/cancer to assess the surrounding tissue for spread. The vaginal "cuff" as it's called (the area at the top of the vagina that was closed when the cervix was removed) is "scraped" very much like a pap smear. The ordering of the pap smear test using a lab slip is required to specify the specimen site (ie, cervix, vaginal cuff, etc).
As an ob/gyn, I don't relish the idea of ill-informed beaurecrats telling me how to practice medicine. The beaurecrats want to automate the practice of medicine so they can pigeonhole all diagnosis and treatments into cubby holes and check boxes in order to analyze and arrive at such statistics as pap smears per hour and state--as if it means something--"Dr B does a pap smear for $3.97 while Dr C charges $3.99." Therefor, we're only going to pay $3.97 for any and all pap smears. Think it sounds funny? That's exactly how Medicare pays, without regard to how easy or difficult it may be to perform a pap smear on various patients. You might just as well say you can reduce all of programming to a universal automated system, plug in a description of inputs and desired outputs and some algorithm generates perfect code. There are many aspects of programming that could be considered an "art form". The same is true with medicine, law, research and a host of other disciplines.
As an ob/gyn, I don't relish the idea of ill-informed beaurecrats telling me how to practice medicine. The beaurecrats want to automate the practice of medicine so they can pigeonhole all diagnosis and treatments into cubby holes and check boxes in order to analyze and arrive at such statistics as pap smears per hour and state--as if it means something--"Dr B does a pap smear for $3.97 while Dr C charges $3.99." Therefor, we're only going to pay $3.97 for any and all pap smears. Think it sounds funny? That's exactly how Medicare pays, without regard to how easy or difficult it may be to perform a pap smear on various patients. You might just as well say you can reduce all of programming to a universal automated system, plug in a description of inputs and desired outputs and some algorithm generates perfect code. There are many aspects of programming that could be considered an "art form". The same is true with medicine, law, research and a host of other disciplines.