All of your arguments here are good ones, and you do a pretty good job of intellectually justifying pirating. But, I can go to YouTube right now and listen to an audiobook that was written by a friend of mine. Yeah, people aren't breaking into his house and stealing his book, but they are using it for entertainment while not paying for it while it is protected under copyright law. Maybe it's not classical theft, but it is a violation of copyright which can be a felony crime. DMCA's provisions are a load of crap and don't provide remuneration for violations. YouTube is only "legal" because the system has failed. Most criminals cook up elaborate justifications for their crimes, but no twisting of words will ever trump the truth. The truth here is that if someone works to create something entertaining or useful, and chooses to copyright it, the copyright should be respected and protected. Otherwise, why pretend that we have copyrights, patents, trademarks, individual identities, personal property, etc.? I know, let's just let the government own everything! That would magically make everyone equal right? Yeah, that's a society I want to live in. One where everything is free yet there is no freedom.